How is Calzaghe P4P(I'm not a hater)?

better question. how is he not?

I don't really see anyone around his weight class that can beat him. hopkins, rjj, glen johnson, tarver are all too old. winky is too small. dawson, taylor, pavlik, miranda, are all vulnerable. Yep..hes right ^^

really???????? I don't really see anyone around his weight class that can beat him. hopkins, rjj, glen johnson, tarver are all too old. winky is too small. dawson, taylor, pavlik, miranda, are all vulnerable.

He means that they are seperated by a few divisions. Shit. I really didn't know that.

He means that they are seperated by a few divisions.

Is it just me or is it full of boxing noobs on here? I mean just the other day I came across a thread where they were discussing who would win between Mayweather vs Calzaghe. For fucks sake. What's your point? You don't rate Calzaghe P4P?

Is it just me or is it full of boxing noobs on here? I mean just the other day I came across a thread where they were discussing who would win between Mayweather vs Calzaghe. For ****s sake. ________ Vaporizers

If you don't know by now then you are no boxing fan. /END exactly.....

The logic is simple. Nobody at this moment in time can beat Calzaghe in his weight range which makes him a P4P. ________ UrLittleAngel

he's top 3.

Top 3 or 4 in most peoples (not haters) books some may even have him 1, or 2 Though I think thats Is slightly high.

If you don't know by now then you are no boxing fan. /END

45-0 :boxing:

He dominated 168 for a decade and beat a top 10 P4Per in Hopkins, although questionably.