Prime James Toney vs. Prime Joe Calzaghe @ LHW

James Toney Joe Calzaghe Who wins at light-heavy, a prime Toney or a prime Calzaghe? my vote is easily Toney toney easily. calzaghe couldn't hurt james EVEN WHEN he does land on james. prime hopkins beats prime joe and i consider toney the better fighter between those 2 HOFers. joe is good but he's nothing special. he has skills but his record benefits from a very , very padded record and a very , very weak division.

WTF? Prime Calzaghe was a SMW and it would all depend which Toney shows up and how weight drained he was. To say easy fight for Toney is ludicrous. now he fights at lhw, he could have done it in the past im sure. i agree toney was inconsistent though that's why i thought this would be an interesting fight.

WTF? Prime Calzaghe was a SMW and it would all depend which Toney shows up and how weight drained he was. To say easy fight for Toney is ludicrous.