Which of the following fighters would be the toughest fight for Mayweather?

Obviously, Kelly Pavlik. The natural size and power advantage would give Mayweather a lot of problems, not to mention Pavlik has a very good jab. In or around his weight division, I have to go with Forrest.

John Ruiz!!!

That tends to happen when there is a rematch. Unless the guy is god, public perception isn't going to have a guy that he has already beaten as his toughest fight. Ricardo Lopez might be the only guy who could claim that. Call me crazy, but I give Oscar a little better chance after seeing him against Forbes, I think the lighter weight agrees with him, and actually forced him to come in in better shape. He'll still lose, and I'd make him about a 3 to 1 dog, but I am liking his chances a bit better than before.

Cotto...............

No votes for Oscar or Hatton? No suprise those two are Floyd's next two likely fights. That tends to happen when there is a rematch. Unless the guy is god, public perception isn't going to have a guy that he has already beaten as his toughest fight. Ricardo Lopez might be the only guy who could claim that.

No votes for Oscar or Hatton? No suprise those two are Floyd's next two likely fights.

lol @ undisputed MIDDLEWEIGHT champ in the list...a little unfair, ya think? #2 Cotto, #3 Forrest.

Winky Wright would be a nightmare for Floyd... No he would be a nightmare for us, this would probably be the most boring fight ever.

Shane Mosley because of his jabs and quick body shots that would bother Mayweather and also Cotto would give him a good fight but it would be close

both Cotto and Margarito are too much for Floyd thats why he wont fight them.

The Undisputed, Undefeated Middleweight Champion of the world Kelly Pavlik is obviously the toughest fight for Floyd....Pavlik would fucking kill Mayweather. QFA. I can't even imagine that fight being remotely close. Floyd wins one round, at most. He probably gets knocked out too.

The Undisputed, Undefeated Middleweight Champion of the world Kelly Pavlik is obviously the toughest fight for Floyd....Pavlik would fucking kill Mayweather.

Pavlik is much too big for Floyd.

mosley will give mayweather all the problem plus mosley will be the bigger man inside the ring.

Winky Wright would be a nightmare for Floyd...

you put pavlike twice but pavlik is a whole different division it's almost a mismatch in size. actually it is! Fuck, I didn't realize that. I shoulda put Margarito instead...

:thinking: why would you put pavlik in there..

you put pavlike twice but pavlik is a whole different division it's almost a mismatch in size. actually it is!

2 votes... 1 for each option of Kelly Pavlik. Pavlik... EASILY. Then probably Forrest. Then Cotto.

Miguel Cotto then Antonio Margarito..