He must have been on drugs when he put this together.....

mayweather 1 no question 2-5 calzaghe hopkins pacman cotto (you decide what order) 5-10 pavlik vasquez wright marquez WLAD(don't hate he's dominant) haye is undisputed and atleast deserves a mention in the top 15 easy dawson abraham aslo top 15

Greg Leon's (B-xingScene.com) top 20 P4P list - Released Today 1 - Pacquiao 2 - Mayweather 3 - Hopkins 4 - Calzaghe 5 - Cotto 6 - Vazquez 7 - Calderon 8 - Pavlik 9 - Wright 10 - Juan Manuel Marquez QUOTE] That is a better top 10. THis is off the dome so don't go insane if i forgot someone.

Why is Tarver on that list? Because Greg Leon is a trash writer who is heavily biased towards certain fighters, especially if they are managed by Al Haymon (Floyd, Taylor, Tarver, Forrest). He is obviously being compensated in some way for his generous rankings.

pacman mayweather calzaghe hopkins vazquez

Hopkins and Wright unjustifiably high on a p4p list? Don't tell me . . . . . Honestly, there's no way either of these guys touches a respectable top ten

Hopkins at 2? I'm probably the biggest Hopkins fan on here and I think that's crazy. I'd have it Mayweather, Calzaghe, Pacquiao, Hopkins, Marquez for my top 5. No way Calzaghe is ahead of Pacquaio or Hopkins right now

Why is Tarver on that list?

yeaa thatz tight where is ma ***** jermang in dis he numba 3 he wuz robbed against pavlik n tha rematch and low blowwed in tha 1st street fight u feel meh. pretty boy floyd and bernawd yeaaaa. how totally inappropriate you are the worst poster ever... bad list i must say

You got borehard slopkins up at number 2 *****WHERE THE FUK IS ROY JONES JR WTFFFFFFFFFFF ***** How the hell does Roy Jones Jr belong top 10 p4p these days?? All he has done is beat Tito In the last god knows how many years

This sucks what a crap list

You got borehard slopkins up at number 2 *****WHERE THE FUK IS ROY JONES JR WTFFFFFFFFFFF *****

Come on, Cotto has destroyed everyone in his path. Did he ever have any questionable decisions? What did Hopkins do? Lost twice to Taylor (no matter how close the fights were) Taylor who has lost to Pavlik x2 and lets agree that the Draw with Wright was a gift decision as well. So he beats Tarver (who is a big question of his own) and fights a 154 ponder at light heavy? Give me a break! UNLESS you add the age factor into this equation.. than to see what Hopkins does at 43 IS amazing! Well the shane mosley fight was damn close. Hopkins destroyed Tarver (where he was a 3-1 underdog) and beat Wright pretty good, where he was also a 2-1 underdog. He's had 20 middleweight defenses and he's 43. Winky wasn't a "154 pounder" as you like to call it. He was fighting at 160 and hadn't fought at 154 for 2 whole years. Winky was #3 p4p when he fought Bernard also. He only had to come up 10 pounds, which almost equals out since it was a catchweight of 170 (unlike where Hopkins had to come up the whole 15)

I have Cotto at 6. I wouldn't put him above Hopkins at all to be honest, though I could have seen him cracking top 5 if Marquez had gotten blown out by Pacquiao. Come on, Cotto has destroyed everyone in his path. Did he ever have any questionable decisions? What did Hopkins do? Lost twice to Taylor (no matter how close the fights were) Taylor who has lost to Pavlik x2 and lets agree that the Draw with Wright was a gift decision as well. So he beats Tarver (who is a big question of his own) and fights a 154 ponder at light heavy? Give me a break! UNLESS you add the age factor into this equation.. than to see what Hopkins does at 43 IS amazing!

Mayweather, Pacquiao, Calzaghe or Mayweather, Calzaghe, Pacquiao is fine by me. Followed by Cotto then Hopkins. I have Cotto at 6. I wouldn't put him above Hopkins at all to be honest, though I could have seen him cracking top 5 if Marquez had gotten blown out by Pacquiao.

by far the most screwed up thing about the boxrec p4p list is that cotto isn't even in the top 25. and yes, mayweather is the only welterweight in the top 25 considering that the welterweight is the most stacked division in boxing. Whenever i get bored or depressed (joke) i read the boxrec p4p it always cheers me up. 1 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight 2 Floyd Mayweather Jr welterweight 3 Kelly Pavlik middleweight 4 Israel Vazquez super bantamweight 5 Manny Pacquiao super featherweight 6 Juan Manuel Marquez super featherweight 7 Rafael Marquez super bantamweight 8 Ronald Wright middleweight 9 Wladimir Klitschko heavyweight 10 David Haye cruiserweight 11 Joe Calzaghe super middleweight 12 Ricky Hatton light welterweight 13 Alexander Munoz super flyweight 14 Chris John featherweight 15 Cory Spinks light middleweight 16 Cristian Mijares super flyweight 17 Nonito Donaire flyweight 18 Celestino Caballero super bantamweight 19 Arthur Abraham middleweight 20 Nate Campbell lightweight 21 Samuel Peter heavyweight 22 Oscar De La Hoya light middleweight 23 Junior Witter light welterweight 24 Joan Guzman super featherweight 25 Juan Diaz Marvel at boxrecs super list lol

Tell me if i am wrong but isn;t that the systme that boxrec use? Cause their p4p list bloody blows! It has Hopkins at number 1 and Witter at 25 with Haye at 20 lol by far the most screwed up thing about the boxrec p4p list is that cotto isn't even in the top 25. and yes, mayweather is the only welterweight in the top 25 considering that the welterweight is the most stacked division in boxing.

Hopkins at 2? I'm probably the biggest Hopkins fan on here and I think that's crazy. I'd have it Mayweather, Calzaghe, Pacquiao, Hopkins, Marquez for my top 5. Mayweather, Pacquiao, Calzaghe or Mayweather, Calzaghe, Pacquiao is fine by me. Followed by Cotto then Hopkins.

Yeah! and iIt's called BoxRec.com lol Tell me if i am wrong but isn;t that the systme that boxrec use? Cause their p4p list bloody blows! It has Hopkins at number 1 and Witter at 25 with Haye at 20 lol yeah but you add in different factors like ways of winning and it should be done by humans.

btalk is a joke of a site.

hopkins beat wright and tarver his last 2 fights so I say he belongs in the top 5. I wouldn't put wright in the top 10 at all. and I agree that haye and wlad not making the top 20 is rediculous. I think haye should be top 5 and wlad top 10.