1- FLOYD MAYWEATHER 39-0
2- MIGUEL COTTO 31-0
3- PAUL WILLIAMS 33-0
4- SHANE MOSLEY 44-5
5- KERMIT CINTRON 29-1
6- ZAB JUDAH 36-5
7- ANTONIO MARGARITO 35-5
8- LUIS COLLAZO 27-3
9- JOSHUA CLOTTEY 33-2
19- CARLOS QUINTANA 24-1
Bonsu, Urkal, Berto as "in the bubble mix."
Next Match-ups...
Williams-Quintana
Margarito-Judah
Cotto- Oscar? Joshua?
Cintron- Clottey? Collazo?
Later this year... if ODLH doesn't fight Cotto
Williams vs. Cintron
Cotto vs. Margarito
By the end of the Year...
Miguel Cotto vs. Paul Williams
Margarito vs. Cintron
It's all good, like you said there is no definitive list. But Margarito held the WBO over 5 years and successfully defended it 7 straight times. He has only lost once in over 11 1/2 years at WW and that was to a top 3 in Williams (the Santos headbutt loss was at 154.)
Kermit is likely better now than he was against Margarito, but he looked terrible against Feliciano (a very questionable defence) and only had to beat Suarez to win a vacated title.
I respect your point of view. Well stated. Remember I am kind of bias since I follow the boricua's fights more than the rest. Even if Kermit is a current tittle holder, I don't give him an edge over Mosley, who undoubtly is better than everyone NOT IN THE TOP 3. Kermit will likely lose his current rank if he loses to any contender just like Margarito did.
Kermit Cintron got a belt. And just like I don't count Margarito early loses prior to Daniel Santos... I don't hold Kermit's loss to Margarito agaisnt him due to unexperience. Right now, I believe Cintron is better than Margarito. Just like Cotto is much much better than 2-3 years ago. I see Zab Judah with 2 significant loses just like Margarito. I believe Judah is better than Margarito. Like in the heading, my top 10. We all have different TOP 10 anyways, lol!
It's all good, like you said there is no definitive list. But Margarito held the WBO over 5 years and successfully defended it 7 straight times. He has only lost once in over 11 1/2 years at WW and that was to a top 3 in Williams (the Santos headbutt loss was at 154.)
Kermit is likely better now than he was against Margarito, but he looked terrible against Feliciano (a very questionable defence) and only had to beat Suarez to win a vacated title.
Champion: Floyd
1. Cotto
2. Williams
3. Mosley
4. Cintron
5. Margarito
6. Clottey
7. Judah
8. Collazo
9. Quitanna
10. Berto
In the mix: Urkal, Gomez, and Bonsu. I'd maybe have Bonsu higher, but I don't know much about him to be honest.
Good list as well. I just got Gomez not cracking the top 15 yet.
Pretty good except Zab is too high after losing 3 in a row. And Marg should be above Cintron based on competition and head to head.
Kermit Cintron got a belt. And just like I don't count Margarito early loses prior to Daniel Santos... I don't hold Kermit's loss to Margarito agaisnt him due to unexperience. Right now, I believe Cintron is better than Margarito. Just like Cotto is much much better than 2-3 years ago. I see Zab Judah with 2 significant loses just like Margarito. I believe Judah is better than Margarito. Like in the heading, my top 10. We all have different TOP 10 anyways, lol!
Champion: Floyd
1. Cotto
2. Williams
3. Mosley
4. Cintron
5. Margarito
6. Clottey
7. Judah
8. Collazo
9. Quitanna
10. Berto
In the mix: Urkal, Gomez, and Bonsu. I'd maybe have Bonsu higher, but I don't know much about him to be honest.