No, I'm not talking about who'd win in a fight between the two. I'm talking records. Which of the two p4p guys do you think has the better record? For me it's a no brainer in picking Mayweather. I believe he faced tougher competition than Roy ever did and has twice as many standouts on his record than Roy. C'mon Roy fans, nows your chance to back Roy up when he needs it. And I'll save you all the trouble..............
Y'ALL MUST'VE FORGOT!!!
Now that that shit's out of the way, vote and post please.
Roy defeated?
Floyd never?
Honestly though I'm talking quality of opposition here, not quantity.
why he retire??/ when times come...
all excuses will pop up..
floyd must fight more to prove...
the irony...
When Roy was p4p and on top of his game, everyone and their mothers talked a lot of shit about him, and how he sucked and so on.
Now that Roy has been found out to be human, and Floyd is p4p and on top of his game, everyone loves Roy and disses Floyd... people are ridicolous.
......................
They were once compareing roy to Ali....lol...ohh the jokes they come up with....roy was a very athletic man but he was never a technical guy...mayweather is both athletic and technical.... when roy slowed down and he wasnt athletic anymore he got got knocked the fuck out....lol.....but the majority speaks .... so i am with the minority on this one..... but most of the world is a bunch of morons including the majority in this poll...stop that dont look around at the next guy like ur not the moron.....
Mayweather is better... Jones got knocked out twice, has the same record as Winky Wright(with out fighting much better comp), and hasn't beaten anybody who he was underdog against.. Why should he be ahead of Floyd?
lOOK aT THE POLL, lOOK AT THE cOMP, NOW tHINK, fLOYD SUCKS BIG MONKEYBRAINS AND rABBITCOCK
Mayweather is better... Jones got knocked out twice, has the same record as Winky Wright(with out fighting much better comp), and hasn't beaten anybody who he was underdog against.. Why should he be ahead of Floyd?
Floyd is still the better all around boxer than Roy Jones. Floyd's only missing power. Jones has been fighting longer than Floyd of course he's gonna have a bigger resume. Stupid ass poll.Of course its a stupid poll, it was done by a mayweather backer, just like yourself
Floyd is still the better all around boxer than Roy Jones. Floyd's only missing power. Jones has been fighting longer than Floyd of course he's gonna have a bigger resume. Stupid ass poll.
This is a freaking silly question. Floyd turned pro eight years after Roy so no one has any idea how it comes out in the wash yet. As of now, Roy's best foes are better than Floyd's and that makes a large gap. Hell, for all the complaints about both over the years, they have a funny way of closing gaps in arguments.
No ,Roy is so much far better in terms of legacy to Floyd that if you see the PEOPLES vote , Roy has been given over 70 votes while Floyd is still on the 30s, Floyds legacy isnt anywhere near Roys
This is a freaking silly question. Floyd turned pro eight years after Roy so no one has any idea how it comes out in the wash yet. As of now, Roy's best foes are better than Floyd's and that makes a large gap. Hell, for all the complaints about both over the years, they have a funny way of closing gaps in arguments.
you obviously dint watch mayweather against NDOU
Yes, yes I did.
I saw Floyd jump in with Right hand, Right hand, Right hand, Right hand and then drop Ndou with two more right hands.
That's more a testament to how Ndou could get hit with a spitball from 100 yards.
Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!
I can see your point but I have a few things I'd like to peacefully disagree with.....
1.) Jones did not win every round against Hopkins, it was a very close fight and most experts seem to agree with Roy taking the fight 7 rounds to 5 or 8 rounds to 4. As for Toney, his physical condition could be argued but I wouldn't bother with it because I think even on his best day Toney can't hold a candle to Roy.
2.) A win over a Heavyweight Champion when moving up in weight is a damn solid accomplishment and I'm not trying to undermind Roy but it was John Ruiz. We're not talking Joe Louis here.
3.) Everybody knows Tarver beat Jones all 3 times they fought. Jones got a gift decision against Tarver the first time out and everybody knew it, that's why they had to make a rematch. Even the crowd booed and chanted "bullshit" when the "decision" was announced.
And Pazienza, Griffin, Harding and Woods are all good fighters but not great. I think we can all agree upon that.
I want more votes!
Roy won that first fight with Tarver, hands down 115-113
I never said anything about singling you out for hating. No doubt that there are many others. I singled you out because I thought perhaps you didn't know how annoying and childish your sexual remarks about another man were (not to mention pretty fucking gay). Not to try turning this around, but you're the one who responded to my post. I put it out there as a joke and you jumped on the oppotunity for me to call you out on your sexual obsession with Floyd. So it kinda sounds like you love me. Sorry but I don't play for that team.
So you see you admitted you are a hypocryte , you also are childish, you also jumped on me by answering back so we both are alike(Only I dont behave like a morality freak,) Calm your nerves, You May through a nervous break down, thats how you sound, You sound stressed out about me hating Floyd that it seems you may burst and and ask Rick Reeno to ban me cause you sound so stressed out.You might have a nervous breakdown
If you want to use facts or logic to discredit a fighter, then that is one thing, but to constantly talk shit about the most ridiculous things is childish and has no place here. This is a boxing forum and you constantly talking about Floyd sexually is wasting space. I was just trying to be nice and help you with your little problem.
Damn!!! i knew i shoulda put 'no haters' when i started this. i'll know better next time.
well, any way, this thread is for civilized discussion only. no haters.
thank you.
But you seem to be obsessed with me then, you are childishly waiting for me to quote, It sounds like you are obsessed with me from what you said, focus on someone else, People will always hate on Floyd , even if i were gone so what then , you will always see Floyd hate all the time, Please, You sound like youre obsessed in me by what you said so focus on something else than me cause people will always hate Floyd, Dont Whine about me hating on Floyd, haters will always be their
You sound in love with me(No B.S)
I never said anything about singling you out for hating. No doubt that there are many others. I singled you out because I thought perhaps you didn't know how annoying and childish your sexual remarks about another man were (not to mention pretty fucking gay). Not to try turning this around, but you're the one who responded to my post. I put it out there as a joke and you jumped on the oppotunity for me to call you out on your sexual obsession with Floyd. So it kinda sounds like you love me. Sorry but I don't play for that team.
I'm not even sure what hypocracy is. (Hypocrisy, perhaps?)
The difference is, as I've told you, that I was just trying to point out that maybe you should stop. It was more for your future benefit than mine. Also, I've posted a couple times about your issues, not one after another, day after day like yourself. And if you would stop asking me quesitons, I'd stop answering.
But you seem to be obsessed with me then, you are childishly waiting for me to quote, It sounds like you are obsessed with me from what you said, focus on someone else, People will always hate on Floyd , even if i were gone so what then , you will always see Floyd hate all the time, Please, You sound like youre obsessed in me by what you said so focus on something else than me cause people will always hate Floyd, Dont Whine about me hating on Floyd, haters will always be their
You sound in love with me(No B.S)
And for that i thank you, i am a bit childish at 20 years old, Im still considered to to be a young man or even a child by my elders so thats why i talk smack about Floyd, im abit childish, i admit if you are honest, you too waste space because you too were asking and waiting for a hater of Floyd to reply when you quoted FLOYD HaTE IS COMING in 3..... 2...1, so that means you were asking for someone like me to answer, Isnt that childish when you ask for something and then you whine about someone like me. See your hypocracy
I'm not even sure what hypocracy is. (Hypocrisy, perhaps?)
The difference is, as I've told you, that I was just trying to point out that maybe you should stop. It was more for your future benefit than mine. Also, I've posted a couple times about your issues, not one after another, day after day like yourself. And if you would stop asking me quesitons, I'd stop answering.
I don't like it when any poster hates on any fighter. If you want to use facts or logic to discredit a fighter, then that is one thing, but to constantly talk shit about the most ridiculous things is childish and has no place here. This is a boxing forum and you constantly talking about Floyd sexually is wasting space. I was just trying to be nice and help you with your little problem.
And for that i thank you, i am a bit childish at 20 years old, Im still considered to to be a young man or even a child by my elders so thats why i talk smack about Floyd, im abit childish, i admit if you are honest, you too waste space because you too were asking and waiting for a hater of Floyd to reply when you quoted FLOYD HaTE IS COMING in 3..... 2...1, so that means you were asking for someone like me to answer, Isnt that childish when you ask for something and then you whine about someone like me. See your hypocracy
Thank ,I Accept, I hate Floyd, thats why i talk crap about Floyd, question back at you Why do you get butthurt if i talk bad about Floyd, Be Honest ,I was honest and said i hate Floyd, I accepted your hater Of the year award, Why do you get so offended if i talk bad about Floyd, Youre probably in love with him, Arent you,Be Honest, Iwas honest when I said i hate Floyd
I don't like it when any poster hates on any fighter. If you want to use facts or logic to discredit a fighter, then that is one thing, but to constantly talk shit about the most ridiculous things is childish and has no place here. This is a boxing forum and you constantly talking about Floyd sexually is wasting space. I was just trying to be nice and help you with your little problem.
Oh and BTW.
I consider Floyd one of the ATG's. Definitely top 20 or 30.
Roy is bar none one of the ten greatest fighters who have ever boxed.
I dont even like gay ass Roy and Roy Jones fans can make a argument to be on top 10 of all time, becausehe is most likely the best in the modern era(Hopkins To me is first, Followed by Roy)Floyd lost again and again on this recent legacy poll, the results were hands down runaway for Roy over Floyd in modern era legacy