Castillo vs Mayweather 1

MW won the event but Castillo won the fight Post your scorecard then

MW won the event but Castillo won the fight

How can it be a robbery when floyd won the 5 rounds clearly and castillo got deducted a point? lol. thats 60 points to mayweather right there, Even that dick Larry Merchant Had mayweather 4-2 up going into round 7, Pure hype from the crappy HBO commentary team, who tried to instigate a robbery, there was no way to score that fight to castillo. Never a robbery, ever. i was sayin it was stupid to call it a robbery, the right man got the decision and still.....no one has a card against floyd lol

My fault forgot about the point reduction. I really go by rounds thaz why I fucked up. I gave Floyd 7 rounds in the fight.

Mayweather won 115-113 in my book. No robbery just a close fight. I don't give a fuck what anyone else thinks. The judges gave it to the correct man although by wide margins. Only haters think it was a robbery which is why I don't give a flying fuck. 115-113 would be impossible in this regard. Perhaps you mean 114-112?

Mayweather won 115-113 in my book. No robbery just a close fight. I don't give a fuck what anyone else thinks. The judges gave it to the correct man although by wide margins. Only haters think it was a robbery which is why I don't give a flying fuck.

Mayweather was robbed in the first fight of his rightful loss

i dnt think anyone that says it was a robbery has seen it lol infact, half the people in this place i would say havent seen the fight, and will prob jst score the close rounds against floyd cos they dnt like him and if the hbo guys gave it against floyd they would take that to, i like to watch fights live, then watch it with no sound on How can it be a robbery when floyd won the 5 rounds clearly and castillo got deducted a point? lol. thats 60 points to mayweather right there, Even that dick Larry Merchant Had mayweather 4-2 up going into round 7, Pure hype from the crappy HBO commentary team, who tried to instigate a robbery, there was no way to score that fight to castillo. Never a robbery, ever.

i dnt think anyone that says it was a robbery has seen it lol infact, half the people in this place i would say havent seen the fight, and will prob jst score the close rounds against floyd cos they dnt like him and if the hbo guys gave it against floyd they would take that to, i like to watch fights live, then watch it with no sound on

We got the same score. Nice. I had it close to you two 115-111 mayweather. No way was that fight ever a robbery in a million years, its obvious some people have not seen the fight.

all ive seen is 3 scorecards lol i guess the "floyd haters" are just haters and not acctually boxing fans and like to slag floyd off

i watched the fight live, and never scored it. but i was shocked with the decision. i thought castillio was robbed, and from what i remembered the analists thought so too. but now that the sweet science is all about points i guess i'll have to buy that fight and score it. but like i said before, from what i saw without scoring it castillio won. i also remember mayweather's face was fucked up too

i say this whole heartdly, the majority of the people on this site dont know how to judge a fight, they dont judge the fight round by round, they judge it by whoever wins the round or rounds they chose to remember! like when people say pacquiao got ripped off vs marquez, how the hell did he get ripped off when he didnt win a round after the 3rd, only thing that saved pacquiao was the first 2 big rounds 10-8 10-7 rounds

Ok, gotta go out, but the first 5 rounds I had Mayweather 10 - 9 Castillo Mayweather 10 - 9 Castillo Mayweather 9 - 10 Castillo* V close round. Mayweather 10 - 9 Castillo Mayweather 9 - 10 Castillo* V close round 3 and 5 were v close. I don't score even rounds unless there is no action, and I just gabe them to Castillo because of Floyd's lack of aggression and his use of the elbow. I'll do a score card carrying on from this but if I scored even rounds in old-school style 3 and 5 would be even.

I'm gonna score the fight now, I have watched it once before but I got distracted from scoring. I reckon I'll score for Mayweather because I tend to favour slick accurate punching rather than pressure, but who knows eh. I don't want any abuse from you guys, otherwise I'll just leave the thread. it's time we all grew up a bit. Laters

This statement is so backwards that its pitiful. If Floyd was boring then wouldnt the thugs be the main guys to hate him? It would seem like thugs would want to see guys who fight like Tyson. How come his PPV numbers are better then just about everyone if people dont like him and think he's boring? What does that say about the other fighters? Also, are you the one that made that racist comment in another thread? I forgot what the person said but that shit sounded racist Dude is racist. he post racist crap all the time and then goes back and deletes the post so he doesnt get banned.

Idiot, I was always a fan of Cotto. I became a bigger fan of him after he destoryed Judah. Beating judah every single round, something floyd couldn't do. And none of you are boxing fans, you're only a fan of floyd mayweathers because he's an African American, you judge him by his skin-tone. Not the fact he's boring. I'm done talking to thugs that can't stop swetting floyd. Stay retired floyd, and hopefully your fans have a drug overdose, so they stop posting on here with their ignorant remarks. My score-card says Castillo won all 12 rounds because floyd runs like a track-star. Come on man, be reasnoble. It was a close fight that Castillo won. Mayweather won the majority of the first half 4-2 most likely. Even if you dislike him be rational man! It was not a 120-108 fight.

Idiot, I was always a fan of Cotto. I became a bigger fan of him after he destoryed Judah. Beating judah every single round, something floyd couldn't do. And none of you are boxing fans, you're only a fan of floyd mayweathers because he's an African American, you judge him by his skin-tone. Not the fact he's boring. I'm done talking to thugs that can't stop swetting floyd. Stay retired floyd, and hopefully your fans have a drug overdose, so they stop posting on here with their ignorant remarks. My score-card says Castillo won all 12 rounds because floyd runs like a track-star. Which just proves I was right all along. Dude, you don't even realize how see-through and transparent you are. It's obvious that you just started watching the sweet science probably months ago, and is totally new to the sport. So instead of just acting like a complete moron, why don't you look up the definition of humility, and actually try to learn something, instead of trying to act like a "know it all". For starters, you can start by watching this fight. It was a good one. Which you can watch right here: http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=118136

Idiot, I was always a fan of Cotto. I became a bigger fan of him after he destoryed Judah. Beating judah every single round, something floyd couldn't do. And none of you are boxing fans, you're only a fan of floyd mayweathers because he's an African American, you judge him by his skin-tone. Not the fact he's boring. I'm done talking to thugs that can't stop swetting floyd. Stay retired floyd, and hopefully your fans have a drug overdose, so they stop posting on here with their ignorant remarks. My score-card says Castillo won all 12 rounds because floyd runs like a track-star. First of all, I'm white, and believe or not, my favorite sport, even above boxing is Tennis. Second of all, I hate basketball (a sport dominated by blacks). I really don't see where you got that from. I'm quite fond of Kessler, Pavlik, and Wlad. I also hate Spinks, Vivian Harris and a lot of other boxers who happen to be black. Race has nothing to do with it, and it's only idiots like you who pull out the race card after you have nothing left to say, as a last resort, after you've been proven wrong repeatedly.

This debate is ruining the thread. Sorry to the thread creator. I am bowing out of this one but will gladly debate it in another thread. This isn't what the thread was made for. DON'T POST UNLESS IT'S A SCORECARD