Don't get me wrong, I like Cotto ...

P4P ratings are subjective. Even the Ring's latest rankings have been called "controversial" by people on this site. Here's G. Leon's top 20: 1. PBF 2. Pac 3. Winky 4. J. Taylor 5. Nard 6. JMM 7. R. Marquez 8. Joe Calzaghe 9. Hatton 10. Castillo 11. Casamayor 12. Mosley 13. DLH 14. Tarver 15. Spinks 16. Cotto 17. MAB 18. Forrest 19. Arce 20. Chico Here's my list: 1. PBF 2. Pac 3. Winky 4. Taylor 5. R. Marquez 6. Joe C. 7. JMM 8. Nard 9. Hatton 10. Castillo 11. Mosley 12. Cotto 13. MAB 14. Arce 15. DLH 16. Chico 17. Spinks 18. Tarver 19 J.M. Mormeck 20. Izzy Vazquez Your list is as bad as Leon's. This is piss-poor.

Castillorank 10 is crazy a guy that can't even make weight. Mosley should be on top of castillo What does making weight have to do with how well you perform your duties inside the square circle? And Castillo should have no problems making 140. He just won't fight at 135 any more (and neither will Chico).

Castillorank 10 is crazy a guy that can't even make weight. Mosley should be on top of castillo

P4P ratings are subjective. Even the Ring's latest rankings have been called "controversial" by people on this site. Here's G. Leon's top 20: 1. PBF 2. Pac 3. Winky 4. J. Taylor 5. Nard 6. JMM 7. R. Marquez 8. Joe Calzaghe 9. Hatton 10. Castillo 11. Casamayor 12. Mosley 13. DLH 14. Tarver 15. Spinks 16. Cotto 17. MAB 18. Forrest 19. Arce 20. Chico Here's my list: 1. PBF 2. Pac 3. Winky 4. Taylor 5. R. Marquez 6. Joe C. 7. JMM 8. Nard 9. Hatton 10. Castillo 11. Mosley 12. Cotto 13. MAB 14. Arce 15. DLH 16. Chico 17. Spinks 18. Tarver 19 J.M. Mormeck 20. Izzy Vazquez

I have friends who write for B-Talk and I always give them shit about how much of a dumbshit Leon is. They never tend to disagree, they just want to move on to other topics.

Barrera at #17 is insane.This guy shouldn't even be allowed to make P4P lists anymore.

FK that dude anyway. I never heard of the prick and probably never will see his named mentioned again

He is obviuosly biased against fighters that give him regular interviews. Like Tarver and Spinks. Also Vernon Forrest made his list. I dont think any of those 3 should be on a top 20 P4P list. Losing to a great fighter doesnt warrant so big a drop (Barrera). Personally, I think thats a pretty bad list. I've noticed his favorable bias in the past for regular contributors to his site but have never spoken on it. Dude should be lethally back-handed.

b o x i n g t a l k . c o m

Which forum are we talking about? lemme know.

The dude is a big Cotto hater, he never gives him credit for anything, I've stopped paying his site any attention.

He is obviuosly biased against fighters that give him regular interviews. Like Tarver and Spinks. Also Vernon Forrest made his list. I dont think any of those 3 should be on a top 20 P4P list. Losing to a great fighter doesnt warrant so big a drop (Barrera). Personally, I think thats a pretty bad list.

Leon's an enigma. ASensation, what's your take on the guy if you're trolling the boards right now?

Sounds like a bias list, the top three spots are not questionable but Cotto and MAB in the lower twenty sound a bit discriminatory by the Cuban.

Thats stupid. One could argue that Barrera deserves to be in the top 10 still.

floyd, pac and wink

Who were the top three?