where does VALUEV rank on your p4p list? is he a all time great?

Has to be one of the stupidiest threads ever.... Only thing Valuev has is SIZE and that he fights BUMS!

Complain? Did you see me complaining? :) Yeah a text book fighter but not a P4P level fighter. I mentioned his size because that's the only thing that gives an advantage to get his victories. The "OLD VITALI" who fought Lewis can send this guiy down crashing to the canvas. As long he doesnt come crashing down on top of the big hitters and score a tko win, he will be beaten soundly

Obviously it came from me, what's your point? He has a size advantage that's all and he kinda knows how to use it... Oh and I'm not saying you hate Valuev, I've noticed some people in this forum do though... only because of his size... I don't think its his size its the fact that hes 46-0, a champoin, approching Marciano's record, but doesn't fight top level opponents. He has one of the most, if not the most, padded record in boxing today.

Valuev is a Roy Jones wannabe.

He is tied with Samson "Dutch Boy" Gym on my special super-duper undefeated p4p list (insert sarcastic grin here)...

Joking or not, this is p4p the stupidest thread of all time and it may never be beaten. Only a complete idiot with a chronic masturbating addiction could come up with such a thread due to lack of testosterone.

His actual skill is underrated for a man of his size. He just too slow to beat Wlad.

All time great? Never, unless he fights 2twice a month and knocks out the Klitschko's, Peter, and any other known Heavy's.

I have Valuev at #2 P4P #1 is Butterbean

He ranks pretty high on my list dispite the fact that he has 320+ lbs to account for so thats really saying something about this ATG!!!11 :nonono:

How stupid could this be? Brian Nielson was 50-0 untill he lost to Dickie Ryan. Let me see you make a case for him ever being ranked in the top ten or as an all time great. Yeah, I have him ahead of Brian Neilson. Valuev is number 3 on my list and Nielson is number 8. I have to give Dickie Ryan the number 7 spot due to his victory over Nielson, plus Nielson is getting old. Actually Dickie Ryan versus Valuev is the big fight I want to see at heavyweight right now.

I think the guy who asked the question is just kidding... How can anyone with half a brain think that Value is anything other than a crooked promotor's creation? Hell,I just read that he is considering TYE FIELDS for his next opponent!!! After that he will probably be fighting another 62 year old. Pound for pound where does he rank?...right after ButterBean Esch.

He is not near the top 10 p4p and he will be koed when he fights a big puncher. (Wlad or Peter will hurt him bad, hell Monte Barret shock Valuev.

He's near the top...just behind Ivan Drago and just ahead of Eric Esch. Hes the future of sucky, circus sideshow, ungainly, uncoordinated semi-boxers. Seriously....the future. No one comes close.

If you say that then you haven't seen any of his fights, he's a good text book kind of fighter and seems to know a lot more about boxing than you guys think. As for the size I don't know why people complain about it or use it as an excuse when it's God given... Indeed. It does seem that its more the case that his size hampers his style and speed, rather than him not having any ability.

valuev would tool carnera, who are we kidding. If valuev fought from 1928-1937, he would have been champ during the whole tenure.

Considering how many pounds he has, I expect him to be knocking out elephants before he makes me top 10 list.

i have him right behind Kimbo on my P4P list!!!!

why is it a joke? i mean the guy is coming up on 50-0..whats all the sarcasim about? How stupid could this be? Brian Nielson was 50-0 untill he lost to Dickie Ryan. Let me see you make a case for him ever being ranked in the top ten or as an all time great. Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

if only shaq had boxing skills i think it would be a good match-*up lmao