Top ten welterweights - where do you rank Margarito?

1) Baldomir 2) Mayweather 3) Hatton (but he's leaving) 4) Judah 5) Margarito

how can mayweather be number 1 hes had 2 fights at welterwieght and theyve come against a washed yup 140 mithcel and a unfocussed zab judah yah p4p hes better but this is a ratings not skills easy because past experience at a lower or higher weight class factors into rating. Thats why when you see a guy move up who was an ex champ he usually falls within the top ten or 15 even though he has no experience at that weight. Mayweather also won a fight against Sharmba Mitchell who was rated within the top 10 to position himself into a title fight. He fought Zab Judah who fell in the rankings but still held a belt. Mayweather took that belt and since Margarito has yet to face a Champion at the 147lb divison or even hold a belt in another weight class he is rated lower. Does this answer your question?

147 champ: baldomir 1. Floyd Mayeather Jr. 2. Zab Judah 3. Paul Williams 4. Luis Collazo 5. Antonio Margarito 6. Kermit Cintron 7. Carlos Quintana 8. Joshua Clottey 9. joel Julio 10. Arturo Gatti oN THE BUTTON M8! :boxing:

147 champ: baldomir 1. Floyd Mayeather Jr. 2. Zab Judah 3. Paul Williams 4. Luis Collazo 5. Antonio Margarito 6. Kermit Cintron 7. Carlos Quintana 8. Joshua Clottey 9. joel Julio 10. Arturo Gatti Good list. Only thing is that I would put Paul Williams ahead of Judah.

Mayweather rates in at number 1 no doubt! U gotta rate Baldi over Judah even tho i think Zab would win a rematch! Margarito is real good but all this "no one will fight me" shit has blown his ability way out of proportion! The winner of Cotto vs Quintana rates real high too! SalvoDominico Collazo is definately top 10 but il forgive u coz Fluffy is so GANGSTA!!!

Theres always a fighter that comes along every so many years that is totally overhyped and exaggerated. Margarito is him. What are people seeing that I don't see? Just saw his fight with Lujan again on ESPN the other night and was reminded at how mediocre he is. Floyd would pick him apart.

how can mayweather be number 1 hes had 2 fights at welterwieght and theyve come against a washed yup 140 mithcel and a unfocussed zab judah yah p4p hes better but this is a ratings not skills

I can't believe there are a so many nuthuggers on this site that actually rank Margarito above PBF. Anyone who does should just stop watching boxing because you obviously don't understand the sport.

Champ: Carlos Baldomir 1.Floyd Mayweather 2.Zab Judah 3.Antonio Margarito 4.Paul Williams 5.Kermit Cintron 6.Carlos Quintana 7.Luis Collazo 8.Joel Julio 9.Oktay Urkal 10.Joshua Clottey Here is my list. if you want the reason why i have people in certain spots holla at me.

I'll say it again Margarito doesnt belong there, keep getting your pussy wet lol You should name yourself Anotnio Margarito because all your posts have to do with him That just proves how idiotic you are. Please get me out of your mind cuz I dont want an e-stalker.

1.Carlos Baldomir 2.Antonio Margarito 3.Floyd Mayweather Jr 4.Kermit Cintron 5.Luis Collazo 6.Zab Judah 7.Paul Williams 8.Oktay Urkal 9.Joshua Clottey 10.Carlos Quintana

Is he really getting to you that bad that you had to look at his past post?? You got it bad dawg Hes just mad cuz I dont agree with collazo being so high. lol all i said was how can he rate collazo #4 when he lost to hatton. he couldve answered it normally but no he started crying about how margarito doesnt belong there. I keep saying whos talking about margarito but he has it in his head that I am. He's insane! I could care less if anyone doesnt like Tony but to call me an idiot and a fool because I do.. who the hell are you? Stupid people.

Personally I don't see Carlos baldomir even in the top 5- Yeh he did beat an seemingly uninterested Zab Judah who had the first few rounds of that fight with ease. Second he beat Gatti who I think is a good fighter but seriously, we all know that Gatti crumbles to anyone who is halfway decent. Somehow Gatti can summon up the will to go to war with journymen like ward but yet gets beat by big head baldi. I don't even know why people are giving him any kind of shot against PBF- and ranking him above PBF is absurd- Yes he is the champ but he is a lucksack and PBF is gonna expose him for the garbage that he is. I know this isn't a bash baldomir thread, but I just saw too many ranking with him above PBF or even in the goddamn top 5. I hope Baldomir gets trashed and embarassed throughly.

Champion: Carlos Baldomir 1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 2. Antonio Margarito 3. Paul Williams 4. Luis Collazo 5. Shane Mosley.....if he ever makes up his damn mind to come back down. 6. Zab Judah 7. Kermit Cintron 8. Miguel Cotto...if he decides to move up. 9. Joel Julio 10. Joshua Clottey

how the hell can u rank hatton #1??? lmao. Put zab in against Hatton at 147 and hatton gets his ass kicked, put in baldy and he gets fucked up even worse they got the belts dude..

Baldomir - He's the linear Champ Margarito - He's been in the division longer than anyone. Mayweather - #1 P4P Collazo Williams Cintron Lazcano Judah Hopkins Clottey

1.mayweather 2.hatton 3.baldy 4.collazo 5.margarito 6.cotto 7.judah 8.williams 9.cintron 10.harris

1. PBF 2. Baldi 3. Margo 4. Zab 5. Kermit 6. Williams 7. Collazo 8. Quintana 9. Clottey 10. Demetrius Hopkins Hatton is not at 147 anymore so he's not in the list. Cotto is about to fight at 147 for the first time, so he's not there, either. If Cotto or Quintana have a good, exciting, impressive fight in December, one of them would move up to #4 or #5.

Lets just be clear, he is no where near #1.

Hatton Baldy PBF Williams Margarito That's the funniest shit I've read all morning