Who is the best middleweight?

B-Hop, the rematch will prove it. End of discussion.

all three are great fighters but bernards getting old and winky is to small...so i would say taylor...not to take anything away from winky or hopkins though

I think it's close between Hopkins and Winky. I give the edge to Hopkins simply because his record speaks for itself. The rematch will prove he's better than Taylor, and in a year Winky will be #1 in the division after Hopkins retires... but as I type this I think I actually can't decide between Winky and Hopkins. Clearly Hopkins has the history, but who wins and who is better right now is basically a tie. i agree its tough to say who the best is, but i believe winky beats hopkins and taylor now, but hopkins has the best record and taylor is the "undisputed" champion. alot more will be clear after the hopkins taylor rematch and after winky's next fight

I think it's close between Hopkins and Winky. I give the edge to Hopkins simply because his record speaks for itself. The rematch will prove he's better than Taylor, and in a year Winky will be #1 in the division after Hopkins retires... but as I type this I think I actually can't decide between Winky and Hopkins. Clearly Hopkins has the history, but who wins and who is better right now is basically a tie.

the battersea bomber!

Hopkins is great but i think Taylor is fully deserving of that title now though.

go to edit in your first post then there should be the option Add poll then that should guide you to do it[/QUOTE

Hopkins is still the best middleweight in the world...that will be proven in the Taylor rematch. How is a man who wins the title without landing 1 significant punch on the champion the best fighter in the world? I still believe Hop is, but I guess we'll see if Taylor is for real in this next fight.

go to edit in your first post then there should be the option Add poll then that should guide you to do it

i think i messed up when trying to make this thread a poll can anybody help me out?