Welterweight (147)

Margarito's biggest problem is not only is he the most dangerous welter, he's also a low key fighter who flies under the public radar. Too much risk and not enough reward to schedule a guy like him. He's a harder punching version of what Winky was through before landing some big fights.

I don't rate Judah that highly but i rate Margarito even less. Exactly what I think. Not to take anything away from Margarito because IMO he's definitely a good fighter but, I would give a slight edge to Judah if they ever fought. I would love to see this matchup or even Margarito and shane but, I don't think shane wants it right now. Not after the way he fought last saturday.

I would say there is a difference between chacing Jay Nady round the ring 20 seconds later and having Zoo hunting you down 10 seconds later with the taste of blood in his mouth if Zab had made the count. no way tszyu would have touched him. the kd happend right at the bell, judah would have had a full minute to recover on his stool and imo would have been in fine condition to begin the next round. nady should not have stopped it, imo...

]] ============================ Zabby is an idiot. Nady could've picked him up and tossed him out of the ring. Zab went down 3x from one punch and just damn lucky Nady's job is to look after his health, because Zab is too stupid to do it on his own.

I don't think he was KOed that hard by Zoo,He went down hard and if he just stayed down and got his marbles rather than jump right back up that would have been a good fight IMO.He was chasing Jay nady all over the ring not 20 seconds after the KD he was not that hurt...Just stunned. I don't think its so much the physical side of getting KO as with Judah V Zoo, its more the mental scar it leaves. a) Judah knows it happened in dramatic circumstances, huge fight, huge pressure, world watching etc etc b) everyone going in with Judah knows about it, knows its possible, knows he may be suspect. I think you make a good point though, he was green and young, a more experienced pro would have taken the count and maybe made it up. I would say there is a difference between chacing Jay Nady round the ring 20 seconds later and having Zoo hunting you down 10 seconds later with the taste of blood in his mouth if Zab had made the count. Furthermore it was such a spectacular KO, so memorable.

Margarito throws more than 100 punches a round like it was nothing. I don't think anyone at 147 can deal with him. Antonio is a huge welter with power and his relentless style will give everyone problems. I think he beats Mosley, Judah, and might as well beat the smaller Mayweather.

I like Margarito in the fight but I worry if he has the skills to deal with Judah. Nobody has tested Judah chin for a while - my money is on it still being a bid dodgy. Once you've taken a huge KO as was dealt to him by Zoo it seems to stick with you. I don't think he was KOed that hard by Zoo,He went down hard and if he just stayed down and got his marbles rather than jump right back up that would have been a good fight IMO.He was chasing Jay nady all over the ring not 20 seconds after the KD he was not that hurt...Just stunned.

I like Margarito in the fight but I worry if he has the skills to deal with Judah. Nobody has tested Judah chin for a while - my money is on it still being a bid dodgy. Once you've taken a huge KO as was dealt to him by Zoo it seems to stick with you.

hmm Margarito is no Cosme Rivera and Judah would probably get stopped by Margarito. Margarito has the chin to deal with whatever shots Judah has to offer, and Tony will just keep coming. And no, he is not innacurate.

I think Judah would win by UD imo,maybe a bad match-up for him stlye wise but I think Judah is pretty damn good and can adjust and get a victory,those are just my thoughts though I see some beg to differ but to each is own. :)

I don't rate Judah that highly but i rate Margarito even less.

]] ========================= Margarito would walk through anything Judah threw and just pound him out, pronto. It's a bad style match for Judah against the scariest welter today.