Canelo Alvarez is an Excellent Fighter... But Not The Best


By Michael Rosenthal

Canelo Alvarez is one of the best fighters in the world. No one would dispute that.

The Mexican redhead built himself into a star even though he had a limited amateur career and was guided by unproven trainers. He has been willing to take on dangerous opponents and has had hand raised in victory more often than not. And, to the detriment of other top middleweights, he seems to be getting better at 28 years old.

All of that is why Alvarez (52-1-2, 35 knockouts) is on every credible pound-for-pound list and deserves to be.

But No. 1? Uh, no.

Some boxing people I respect have begun to suggest that Alvarez is the best active fighter, particularly after his close, but unanimous-decision victory over formidable Daniel Jacobs last Saturday night in Las Vegas.

They’ll point to his body of work, including dominating victories over second-tier opponents and a winning record against elite foes.

For the purposes of this column, let’s say he has faced seven opponents who were given some chance to beat him – Austin Trout, Floyd Mayweather, Erislandy Lara, Miguel Cotto, Gennady Golovkin (twice) and Jacobs.

Alvarez is 5-1-1 in those fights, an impressive run that has allowed him to climb up the pound-for-pound ladder over the past several years and one reason some believe he has leapfrogged Vasyl Lomachenko and Terence Crawford.

canelo-alvarez (1)_22

But let’s take a closer look at those fights:

• Trout, UD: I thought the fight was much closer than at least one of the scorecards (118-109) indicated but it was a clear victory.

• Mayweather, UD loss: I scored the bout 120-108 – a shutout – for Mayweather. Enough said.

• Lara, SD: Kudos to Alvarez for facing the master technician from Cuba and he performed well but many believe Lara deserved the victory or at least a draw.

• Cotto, UD: The Puerto Rican star was on a nice little run but his victory over a gimpy Sergio Martinez to win the WBC middleweight title was misleading. Cotto was in decline.

• Golovkin, SD draw and MD: The first fight was competitive but the vast majority of observers thought Triple-G won. The second fight, a victory for Alvarez, also was controversial.

• Jacobs, UD: Alvarez turned in a good performance against a bigger man in a mildly entertaining fight. The scorecards reflected what happened in the ring.

Of course, Alvarez deserves credit for winning five of the seven aforementioned fights and performing well in the draw. The primary object of boxing is to win, after all.

At the same time, we can’t ignore the fact that he was fortunate that the judges handed him a record of 2-0-1 against Lara and Golovkin. Some knowledgeable observers would suggest Alvarez should be 0-3 in those fights, which obviously would’ve changed the way he’s perceived.

And in none of those fights did Alvarez dazzle anyone. He does just enough to win (or draw) in his biggest fights, which leaves him without that “wow” factor or a true defining fight to separate him from others contending for the top spot on the pound-for-pound list.

Consider two past pound-for-pound kings. Mayweather dominated almost everyone he faced, which made the best fighter of his era. Manny Pacquiao knocked out in succession Oscar De La Hoya, Ricky Hatton and Miguel Cotto. Alvarez can’t match that level of dominance.

And let’s compare Alvarez to today’s top two fighters, Lomachenko and Crawford.

The original purpose of pound-for-pound was to compare fighters without regard to weight. And I’ve always seen the pound-for-pound formula as a balance between important victories and the eye test, meaning winning or eye-catching performances alone aren’t necessarily enough to land at No. 1.

The opponents of Lomachenko (13-1, 10 KOs) don’t rival Alvarez’s victims – it’s hard to top the challenges presented by Lara, Triple-G and Jacobs – but “Hi-Tech” has a strong resume, including victories over Gary Russell Jr., Roman Martinez, Nicholas Walters, Guillermo Rigondeaux and Jorge Linares.

And I would argue that Lomachenko has been more impressive than Alvarez in his biggest fights. A clear victory over Russell and knockouts of Martinez, Walters, Rigondeaux and Linares (after some trying moments for Lomachenko) were spectacular, a word few would use to describe Alvarez’s performances in his seven biggest fights.

Indeed, I believe Lomachenko blows Alvarez away in terms of the eye test. Alvarez is an excellent, unusually durable boxer but “Hi-Tech” has a skill set that leaves onlookers in awe.

Crawford (35-0, 26 KOs) also falls short of Alvarez in level of opposition but he, too, has a strong resume. Among his opponents: Ricky Burns, Yuriorkis Gamboa, Ray Beltran, Thomas Dulorme, Viktor Postol and Amir Khan (at a natural weight for Khan).

And, like Lomachenko, the Nebraskan was more impressive – and certainly more dynamic – in these fights than Alvarez has been in his toughest challenges, meaning Crawford has earned a higher grade on the eye tests. There have been a lot of “wows” in the career of Terence Crawford.

This leads me to an obvious question predicated on the purpose of pound-for-pound: Do you seriously believe that Alvarez would beat Lomachenko and Crawford if they were legitimate 160-pounders? Think about that for a while and get back to me.

For the record, this column isn’t meant to demean Alvarez in any way. Again, he’s one of the best at what he does. He should take pride in that.

And one day he might climb to the No. 1 positition. For example, a dominating victory in a third fight with Golovkin might be that “wow”  or defining victory that would help build a stronger case that he belongs at the top of the boxing heap.

But that time hasn’t come. Right now, Lomachenko and Crawford are the best fighters in the world.

Michael Rosenthal was the 2018 winner of the Boxing Writers Association of America’s Nat Fleischer Award for excellence in boxing journalism. He has covered boxing in Los Angeles and beyond for almost three decades. Follow him at @mrosenthal_box.

Tags: Saul Alvarez image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by WOKnWOH on 05-17-2019

[QUOTE=Mikr69103;19733764]Has crawford or Loma faced anyone close to beign on the top ten pound for pound list and the answer is no crawford wont fight spence and Loma wont fight Mikey.. thats the difference Canelo fought pound for pound guy…

Comment by aboutfkntime on 05-16-2019

[QUOTE=Joshyohno;19745711]Wtf is this Rosenthal bum even talking about? Pfp? I think he forgot to mention the fact that Canelo has gone up a few weight classes since becoming a champion. He's now facing naturally larger men. Larger skilled fighters with…

Comment by Joshyohno on 05-15-2019

Wtf is this Rosenthal bum even talking about? Pfp? I think he forgot to mention the fact that Canelo has gone up a few weight classes since becoming a champion. He's now facing naturally larger men. Larger skilled fighters with…

Comment by aboutfkntime on 05-13-2019

[QUOTE=stealthradon;19739683]Much better? Name the fighters he fought in their prime, and then destroyed?[/QUOTE] he did not destroy Jacobs you muppet :lol1: he destroyed flat-footed made-to-order opponents who would be "[I]available[/I]"..... and he did that because..... they are the opponents he…

Comment by aboutfkntime on 05-13-2019

[QUOTE=R_Walken;19739115]Man stop it , the useless #1 P4P ranking is just a way for media / fans to have something to about Especially if there’s no clear cutn#1 like a Mayweather / Ward most of its just a way…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (324)
Top Headlines Joyce: Ustinov Win Proves I'm A Credible Opponent For Joshua Donaire: Figuring Out How To Beat Naoya Inoue Gets Me Excited! Deontay Wilder: Why Not Have Two, Three Fights With Luis Ortiz? Prograis vs. Taylor Will Have More at Stake Than WBSS Throne Dubois Plans To Do Damage on Gorman, Make a Statement Harvey Horn Added To Dubois-Gorman After Moving To 6-0 Wilder: Breazeale's Body Language Changed After First Right Whyte: Fury Makes No Sense, He's Always Contradicting Himself! Ronald Johnson Returns To The Ring on 6/15 in The Phillipines Raquel Miller, Jonathan Esquivel Get KO Wins at Gardens Casino Wilder Forces Us To Confront Our Fears & Joys In Boxing Fandom Roach Expects Pacquiao's Speed To Be Too Much For Thurman Wilder Manager Sees Joshua or Fury as More Likely For 2020 Kiko Martinez Plans To Return To 122-Pounds, Eyes World Title Ugas Hopes a Win Over Omar Figueroa Leads To World Title Shot Jeyvier Cintron Feels No Pressure Ahead of Koki Eto Eliminator Wilder: This Won't Be Like Lewis-Bowe, Joshua FIght Will Happen Jhonny Gonzalez Blasts Out Rafael Hernandez For Regional Belt Tyson Fury Praises Wilder For Big KO, Takes Dig at Joshua Photos: Gary Russell Jr. Retains, TKO of Kiko Martinez in Five Lipinets-Molina Targeted For July 20 Pacquiao-Thurman PPV Alantez Fox Drops, Stops Nick Brinson in Sixth Round Felix Alvarado Gets Dominant Win Over Reiya Konishi Juan Manuel Lopez, Emiliano Garcia Ends in a Majority Draw Jesus Rojas Drops Luis Castillo Three Times For TKO in Three Naoya Inoue: I Look Forward To Fighting Nonito Donaire Argenis Mendez: I Thought I Won, He Didn't Do Anything To Me Saunders: I Want Callum Smith - Canelo, GGG Don't Want My Style Gary Russell Puts Pressure on Haymon To Get Leo Santa Cruz Wilder: I Promise You, Have Patience, Joshua Fight Will Happen Photos: Deontay Wilder Brutally Blasts Breazeale - HUGE Gallery Josh Taylor Confident: Regis Prograis is Great - But I'll Beat Him Kevin Lerena vs. Vasil Ducar on June 8 in Emperors Palace Hearn: Wilder's Win Impressive, Joshua Fight Must Happen Next Video: Gary Russell Jr. Discusses TKO of Martinez, The Future Video: Andre Rozier Reacts To Deontay Wilder's KO of Breazeale Video: Deontay Wilder's Trainer Reacts To KO of Breazeale Video: Deontay Wilder Reacts To Vicious KO of Breazeale Deontay Wilder: I Told Breazeale I Love Him, We Shook Hands Deontay Wilder Could Be Ringside For Joshua vs. Ruiz at MSG

Latest Active Forum Threads