Advertisement: IBO Boxing

BoxingScene Awards 2020: The Best of The Rest - Trainer, Round, Comeback, More


Throughout the week, BoxingScene has provided readers their choices for the annual boxing Oscars (or Emmys, or Golden Globes, or Nickelodeon Kids or whatever trophies one most anticipates).

The top honors, for Fighter (Teofimo Lopez) and Fight (Jose Zepeda-Ivan Baranchyk), were well deserved and the latter may be in the running for Fight of the Decade. While it wasn’t for a title, a war like that between two consensus top ten fighters in their division doesn’t come along every day.

Along with Knockout, Upset, and Prospect of the Year, much of the best of the wild year that was 2020 has been covered.

Much, but not all.

To close out 2020 awards season here, let’s present some additional selections the year would not be complete without mentioning.

Round of the Year: Jose Zepeda-Ivan Baranchyk Round Five

Fights might be viewed as a whole but they are in part a series of fights between two combatants over a predetermined limit. Each block of three minutes, whether the contest is set for six, eight, ten, or twelve rounds, is its own drama but built off the foundation of the drama preceding it. It’s why a fight like Sergio Martinez-Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. can remain fondly remembered. Eleven rounds of tedium? Sure. But, oh, that twelfth and final round…

The 2020 Fight of the Year could likely fill multiple slots in round of the year voting but the choice here is the fifth and final of a scheduled ten. There were more frenzied frames but after trading six official, and what really should have been seven, knockdowns through the first four rounds, we got a hell of a finish. Baranchyk, dropped and hurt late in the fourth, responded and was firing back again as both men met each other with caution and the pursuit of an opening. In the final minute, Baranchyk exploded with a shot to drive Zepeda into the ropes for the seventh knockdown, the referee noting the ropes had kept Zepeda up. Barachyk came forward for the finish and was met with a left hand that folded him into the floor for the last time. It was a fitting, concussive finish to a classic.   

Honorable Mention: Gervonta Davis-Leo Santa Cruz Round 6, Juan Francisco Estrada-Carlos Cuadras Round 5, Tyson Fury-Deontay Wilder Round 3, Chris Colbert-Jaime Arboleda Round 9


Trainer of the Year: Derrick James

The fighter is ultimately responsible for what happens in the ring. We can never underestimate the minds at work in preparing them. To have a couple of unified titlists under the same wing would be impressive no matter what divisions it came in. To have them in arguably two of the deepest and most talented classes in boxing is another matter.

Derrick James can make that claim with big wins in 2020 from both Jermell Charlo and Errol Spence, under very different circumstances. With the former, James guided Charlo in October to the top of the mountain in a still ongoing, multi-year round robin at Jr. middleweight. In a fight still competitive on the cards, Charlo landed a whale of a body shot to add Jeison Roasrio’s WBA and IBF belts to the WBC crown Charlo already has on his shelf.

In December, James cornered the return of already unified WBC/IBF welterweight titlist Errol Spence. Spence, just a year prior, was involved in what could easily have been a fatal car crash. James had him sharp and back to form in a decision win over game, tested former lineal Jr. welterweight king Danny Garcia.

Good fighters would likely be gems under the tutelage of many but great trainers can be the difference between good and great. As Spence and Charlo have continued to evolve and deepen their resumes, the common denominator stands out in a year when both posted elite victories. Derrick James is the Trainer of the Year.

Honorable Mention: Roberto Garcia, Sugar Hill, Teofimo Lopez Sr., Eddy Reynoso, Ismael Salas

Event of the Year: COVID

Nothing defined 2020 more, in boxing and in the world at large, like the global COVID-19 pandemic. It shut down chunks of the engine of the world and sent sports to the sidelines. In boxing, it meant innovation. The ESPN bubble series and Eddie Hearn’s back yard were among the new locations fight fans got used to. Blurred out fan backgrounds added an odd aesthetic for Fox shows. Positive tests meant having to be flexible to change cards on the fly.

All of it resulted in action getting back in the ring with as much safety as possible. By year’s end it also meant fans in big arenas spaced out in ways that returned ambience but never let us forget the era we were watching in. Sometime in 2021, vaccines will mean fuller crowds and richer events. In 2020, boxing fought back against the times and still found a way to deliver a knockout fall schedule. We’re unlikely to see another year like it.

Let’s damn sure hope so.

Honorable Mention: Tyson Fury-Deontay Wilder II, Showtime’s Fall Schedule Announcement, The Charlo Pay Per View Doubleheader, Teofimo Lopez-Vasyl Lomachenko, Gervonta Davis-Leo Santa Cruz 

Network of the Year: ESPN

This was a tough call between ESPN and Showtime. Showtime beat everyone to the punch in announcing a deep fall slate that created instant anticipation. ESPN countered by making the best fight possible at lightweight, Teofimo Lopez-Vasyl Lomachenko, to stellar ratings relative to the sweet science. They also delivered the Fight of the Year, the US return of Naoya Inoue through their Plus service, Joe Joyce-Daniel Dubois, and Joe Smith-Eleider Alvarez. As the year is the sum of all its parts, ESPN being half of the biggest money fight of the year (Fury-Wilder II) and the bubble gem that was Joshua Franco’s upset of Andrew Moloney also factor in their favor.

Most of the major networks and streaming services delivered some serious quality this year, before and after COVID. ESPN by a hair may have had the most consistent of any. Kudos though to every network that put their best foot forward and made the most of 2020.

Honorable Mention: Showtime, DAZN

Comeback of the Year: Errol Spence

We all make mistakes in life. Some can be fatal, for ourselves or others. Getting behind the wheel under the influence is a mistake that can add up to both. Errol Spence made a mistake and when news came about his auto accident in 2019, followed by footage of the wreck, it was easy to worry first about whether he would survive and then whether he would return to the ring. In a best case scenario, the answer to both questions was yes. The most people can often do is learn and be better after their bad days. Spence, without a tune-up, came back to face a serious contender and looked nearly as good as he did before the accident, some brief breather rounds late being the only notable dip in the return.

No one could know until Spence was back in the ring just what he would look like and how his body might respond to the body trauma effects of his accident when hit. The world found out as Spence resumed his position as the leader at welterweight. It was the most dramatic comeback story of 2020.

Honorable Mention: Roman Gonzalez

Best wishes and health to everyone who takes a moment to read us here at BoxingScene for the rest of 2021.                 

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, a member of the International Boxing Research Organization, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by budfr on 01-10-2021

It should have been Reynoso. These reporters have a pro Afro-American agenda.

Comment by Rcralas on 01-10-2021

Salas should of been trainer of the year making his both underdog fighters win their marches (Joyce vs Dubois and Ioka vs Tanaka)

Comment by Bronx2245 on 01-10-2021

Salute to Derrick James! Hopefully Jermell Charlo gets the winner of Teixeira vs. Castano, for the undisputed at 154!

Comment by The D3vil on 01-10-2021

Good picks, but I think picking COVID as a boxing event is a little bit of a cop out I would've gone with Fury over Wilder

Comment by Onetimethun on 01-10-2021

I had reynoso as trainer Of the year

Top Headlines
Josh Warrington Furious With Xu Can's Refusal To Fight Behind Closed Doors Leo: I Have A Lot Of Doubters & I’m The Underdog Against Fulton; All Fuel To Flame Hearn: Garcia Is Not Ready For Davis, Deal For Haney vs. Garcia Will Be Easier To Make Warren: A Joyce-Usyk Fight Puts Winner In Tremendous Position The Greatest Encore: Ranking the Best Heavyweights Since Ali Tszyu-Hogan: Stapleton vs. Colosimo in Works For Proposed Card Luis Nery Aims To Have Unification in Next Fight, Says Promoter Deontay Wilder vs. Dillian Whyte Would Be Massive Fight, Says Hearn Tommy Frank vs. Kyle Yousaf British Title Clash May Land in April Stephen Fulton Overcomes The Nightmare of COVID; Realizes Dream Of Fighting For World Title Ryan Garcia's Father: Lopez is Not 'King' at 135, He Beat a 130-Pounder Vergil Ortiz: I Want All The Belts, No Easy Fights, I Want To Face The Best Reynoso: Berchelt Can End a Fight With One Punch - But So Can Valdez! Munguia's Promoter Hopes To Secure Golovkin Title Clash Usyk vs. Joyce Clash is Being Discussed, Says Frank Warren Carlos Gongora Inks Promotional Pact With Eddie Hearn Ryan Garcia's Father Backs Son's Two Round KO Prediction of Gervonta Davis Samuel Vargas Aims To Use Experience To Shock Conor Benn Dylan Price Takes Out Samuel Gutierrez in Four Rounds Bob Arum: Golden Boy Wouldn't Put Ryan Garcia In With Teofimo Lopez; Easy Work Angelo Leo: Always Wanted To Celebrate Title Win With A Crowd, More Motivation To Stay Champion Thurman To Arum: Stop Talking Sh-t! Not My Fault You Can’t Afford Fight For Crawford Michel Rivera: Ryan Garcia Has a Great Punch But a Glass Chin Hearn Says Boxing Events Must Continue or Sport Could Fizzle Out McGirt Was Unaware of Kovalev's Doping Test, Felt Camp Was Going Well Manager: Pacquiao or McGregor Would Beat Mayweather in Rematch Dominic Breazeale Vows To Blast Out Otto Wallin With Huge Knockout Fred Levin: An Appreciation (1937-2021) Sergio Martinez Working For April Return, Eyes Murata Shot By Year's End Thunderdome Boxing Series Returns on February 26 in Perth Arum on Lopez's Options: Haney Doesn't Mean Much, Not an Attraction Like Davis, Garcia Talks Progress For Canelo Alvarez To Move Forward With Matchroom/DAZN Ivan Golub, Melissa Oddessa, Joe Williams Back on February 20 Inoue-Dasmarinas: Date, Site Of Fight Depends On COVID-19 Restrictions In Japan Junior Cruzat To Fight For WBA Regional Title on February 26 Joshua-Fury: Hearn Wants Second Fight in Cardiff, But Says Pressure May Stop It Buddy McGirt Predicts Shakur Stevenson Gets KO'ed by Teofimo Lopez, Starts Heated Squabble Artur Beterbiev Co-Trainer: Bivol Is The Most Important Fight At 175 Plant: At Some Point, Me And Canelo Are Gonna Get In There And Do Our Thing Josh Warrington May Vacate IBF Title, Fight Gary Russell Jr.
Latest Forum Threads