Tyson Fury's Still a Star, But He's Not The Heavyweight Champion


Let’s make a few things clear.

I admire, respect, and yeah… I even like Tyson Fury.

The British big man boxed Wladimir Klitschko’s ears off in a fight I never thought he’d win. He rose from a Deontay Wilder combo that I thought had surely stopped him. And he fought through a mask of bloody adversity on Saturday night that would’ve caused many other men to cede their superiority.

He’s a heavyweight stud on the highest of levels these days.

But while we’re at it, let’s make another thing clear as well.

He’s not the heavyweight champion.

Regardless of how many times Top Rank writes press releases or creates graphics that say so, or how many times clueless ESPN SportsCenter anchors read it from teleprompters – it’s simply not the case.

Oh, he certainly was at one point.

In the moments following the herky-jerky clinic that vanquished long-reigning Ukrainian behemoth Klitschko back in 2015, he was a microphone-grabbing, Aerosmith-bellowing master of all he surveyed.

But then he wasn’t.

When a series of physical, personal and sanctioning demons consecutively combined to snatch his health, his wellness and his collection of gaudy hardware, and forced him to the sidelines for more than 30 months – or 924 days, to be exact – he relinquished any claim to be the king of the division.

Was he still a world-class fighter? Of course.

Did he still warrant legacy consideration for a title shot? Definitely.

But to suggest that he could simply walk away – voluntarily, or not – and return after such a long absence as if nothing at all had changed is patently ridiculous.

Don’t think so?

tyson-fury (6)_8

OK, imagine if the same sort of logic held true in other scenarios.

Peyton Manning exited Levi’s Stadium in February 2016 – a couple months following Fury’s defeat of Klitschko – after winning Super Bowl 50 with the Denver Broncos, then retired. Would he have still had a right to claim world champion status had he decided to come back with the Broncos last season?

Pete Sampras won the 14th Grand Slam singles title of his tennis career at the 2002 U.S. Open, then strode away into competitive inactivity. Had he returned a few years later among the Federers, Nadals and Djokovics of the on-court world, would he have been given an automatic berth into slam finals?

Here’s a hunch… your answers were no, and no.

So why then, is boxing any different?

As it happens, no less a biblical authority than Ring Magazine – yes, the oft-proclaimed savior of all things gloved – has a laundry list of ways via which a fighter it deems a champion can lose his status.

And items No. 3, 4 and 5 on that list happen to stipulate the following:

3) The Champion does not schedule a fight in any weight class for 18 months.
4) The Champion does not schedule a fight at his championship weight for 18 months (even if he fights at another weight).
5) The Champion does not schedule a fight with a Top-5 contender from any weight class for two years.

Lest anyone forget, Fury falls flat on all three requirements.

So, by doing so – regardless of the reason for his absence, or the presence of a worthy successor upon his exit – he abdicates the throne. And if it’s good enough for Ring, it’s good enough for me.

Still, Top Rank and ESPN continue to bang the nonsensical promotional drum.

As the Sunday morning SportsCenter crew fell over itself heralding Fury’s night-before defeat of Otto Wallin – the world’s 26th-best active heavyweight, by the way – the silliness reached epic proportions.

A post-fight list suggested Fury was one of a handful of elite heavyweights who’d defended his title five times while maintaining an unbeaten record.

But while you’re busy contemplating where the Brit belongs among historic names like Holmes, Marciano, Tyson and others, also remember that his other title “defenses” came in wins over the forgettable likes of Sefer Seferi, Francesco Pianeta and Tom Schwarz, and a draw against Wilder in which exactly one of three judges gave him a scorecard nod.

Seferi, a 40-year-old Albanian who’ll fight for the IBO cruiserweight title this weekend, was ranked 50th among heavyweights – according to the Independent World Boxing Rankings – when he got in with Fury in June 2018 and weighed 210 pounds to the so-called champion’s 276.

Pianeta, incidentally, was ranked 69th and Schwarz was 48th when they got their “shots.”

They were 82-5-1 collectively. But had never beaten anyone ranked better than 89th.

Not exactly the Murderers Row of modern big men.

And in other words, the next time Fury defeats a top-10 heavyweight – actually, make that a top-25 heavyweight – in a nearly four-year post-Klitschko run as “champion,” it’ll be the first time.

Now, I can’t pretend to speak for Bob Arum or Jimmy Pitaro, but I’d like a little more from my top guy.

Shouldn’t you?

* * * * * * * * * *

This week’s legit title-fight schedule:


IBO cruiserweight title – Kempton Park, South Africa
Kevin Lerena (champion/No. 5 IWBR) vs. Sefer Seferi (No. 30 IBO/No. 46 IWBR)
Lerena (23-1, 10 KO): Fifth title defense; Decision wins in five of eight 12-rounders (8-0, 3 KO)
Seferi (23-2-1, 21 KO): First title fight; Never a lost a fight at 200 pounds or less (12-0-1, 11 KO)
Fitzbitz says: Betting on 40-year-old Albanians to win title fights is rarely – if ever – a wise strategy. So, while Seferi has a resume that tops all Lerena’s foes, it likely won’t matter. Lerena by decision (65/35)

Last week's picks: 3-0 (WIN: Ponce, Munguia, Navarrete)
2019 picks record: 73-14 (83.9 percent)
Overall picks record: 1,084-357 (75.2 percent)

NOTE: Fights previewed are only those involving a sanctioning body's full-fledged title-holder – no interim, diamond, silver, etc. Fights for WBA "world championships" are only included if no "super champion" exists in the weight class.

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by john l on 09-18-2019

[QUOTE=HeadBodyBodyBody;20066066]I meant the Rochin card in particular, which was clearly corrupt. People who say that Wilder won against Fury are in the extreme minority, and are simply wrong in my opinion. In the case of Hopkins, I think he's a…

Comment by Boksfan on 09-18-2019

Fat Fury is not a champion because he was cheating using steroids and that's a fact.

Comment by The D3vil on 09-18-2019

[QUOTE=factsarenice;20064910]So by your logic champions are for life and they can come back matched with cabbies and remain the real lineal champion. Lennox can come back and be a co-champion with Fury and fight Erick Berk or Bobby Leach and…

Comment by HeadBodyBodyBody on 09-18-2019

[QUOTE=john l;20065425]Don't think there was a prob with scoring, I had it a draw and some writers like D Rafiel and B Campball had him winning. To answer your question if Fury beats Wilder would I consider him the REAL…

Comment by Mrsantiago on 09-18-2019

[QUOTE=G G G;20063823]He’s a runner and a hugger, a coward inside and outside the ring. Zero respect.[/QUOTE] Well people are gonna praise him because he’s the antithesis to power punching Deontay Wilder. People (fans/media) claim they want to see knockouts…

Top Headlines
Dmitry Bivol Impressed, Very Eager To Fight Artur Beterbiev Ryad Merhy Blasts Out Imre Szello To Capture WBA Interim Title Lewis Ritson Fights Through Fire To Decision Robbie Davies Lewis Ritson-Robbie Davies - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Scott Fitzgerald Beats Ted Cheeseman With Controversial Decision Scott Fitzgerald-Ted Cheeseman - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Savannah Marshall Wants World Title Shot After Three-Round TKO Arum: Gvozdyk Was Winning When Beterbiev Stopped Him Ritson-Davies LIVE Results - Martin Bakole Stops Kevin Johnson Kudratillo Abdukakhorov: I Want Errol Spence Title Fight Next! Lomachenko, Usyk Hold "Meet & Greet' in Philadelphia Yilrdirim: I Am Happy It Is On Paper That I Am A Clean Fighter Kudratillo Abdukakhorov Boxes Past Luis Collazo Artur Beterbiev Aims To Capture More Gold at 175 Beterbiev Breaks Down, Stops Gvozdyk To Unify Titles Daily Bread Mailbag: Wilder-Ortiz, GGG-Derevyachenko, More Fury, Loma, Lopez, Commey, Usyk Hit Beterbiev-Gvozdyk Alex Dilmaghani vs. Francisco Fonseca Rescheduled For Nov. 16 Mayweather: Gervonta Davis is Unbelievable, They Can't Stop Him Frank Warren on Passing of Patrick Day, Dubois vs. Allen Update Artur Beterbiev vs. Meng Fanlong is Next, Says Bob Arum Beterbiev vs. Gvozdyk - CompuBox Punch Stats Artur Beterbiev vs. Oleksandr Gvozdyk - Official Scorecards Beterbiev Drops Gvozdyk Three Times, Stops Him in Tenth Emanuel 'Pinky' Colon Blasts Out Richard Zamora In One Beterbiev vs. Gvozdyk - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Abdukakhorov Beats Injured Collazo By Technical Decision Collazo vs. Abdukakhorov - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Julian Rodriguez Drops, Stops Doronio In Sixth Round Beterbiev-Gvozdyk - LIVE Results From Philadelphia Oleksandr Gvozdyk-Artur Beterbiev: Stats & Stakes Benavidez-Yildirim Approved By WBC, Doping Investigation Finished Tutico Zabala Thrilled With Buffalo's Embracing Of Telemundo Show Beterbiev: I'm Very Simple, Like To Live My Life Separate From Boxing Callum Johnson: Canelo Beats Kovalev, Beterbiev Edges Gvozdyk Lubin: 154 is Best Division in Boxing, But None Are Unbeatable Scott Fitzgerald, Ted Cheeseman - Ready For Battle Lewis Ritson, Robbie Davies - Set For Grudge Match Beterbiev: Can’t Think I’ll KO Gvozdyk Due To Amateur TKO Artur Beterbiev: Knockout Streak 'Not Important' To Me
Latest Forum Threads