Shawn Porter Has a Plan To Change The Way He's Perceived


By Michael Rosenthal

Shawn Porter is already perceived as an accomplished fighter.

The one-time amateur standout has been among the best welterweights in the world for six-plus years, he has won two major titles and he has victories over Devon Alexander, Paulie Malignaggi, Adrien Broner, Andre Berto and Danny Garcia. And his two losses, to Kell Brook and Keith Thurman, were close, competitive battles.

Most boxers would be thrilled to have such a resume. Porter? He’s not content. He has a plan in place to radically change the way he’s seen by pundits and fans. And it seems feasible, assuming he beats Yordenis Ugas on Saturday in Carson, California.

Porter, the WBC titleholder, wants to fight – and plans to beat – fellow elite 147-pounders Manny Pacquiao, Keith Thurman and Errol Spence in the near future.

That’s a big wish list, particularly the “beat” part, but it could happen. One, all four principals fight under the Premier Boxing Champions banner, meaning negotiations shouldn’t be difficult. And, two, Porter is an attractive opponent for any of his rivals.

Pacquiao needs a fighter who will come to him at this stage of his career. That’s Porter, a high-energy opponent who stays in your face from beginning to end. If I were advising Pacquiao, I would strongly recommend that he choose Porter over the quicker, more-careful Thurman and Spence.

Thurman narrowly outpointed Porter (115-113 on all cards) in an essentially even fight in June 2016. Thus, their rematch already has a back story. Fans would embrace that matchup. Plus, Thurman, the WBA champ, would be motivated to unify two titles.

The same goes for Spence, the IBF titleholder. Porter and Thurman are equally attractive to Spence because they both hold major belts.

Of course, I have no idea whether Porter can get any of these potential opponents into the ring. Everyone and their mothers want Pacquiao because of the money the popular Filipino generates. And money supersedes anything, including titles.

Porter could win the Pacquiao sweepstakes but there is a lot of competition. Maybe it’s him, maybe it’s Thurman, maybe it’s the winner of the Spence-Mikey Garcia fight on March 16. Garcia, if he upsets Spence, would be an ideal opponent for Pacquiao because of his smaller stature.

And if Porter doesn’t fight Pacquiao, again, he would be attractive to whichever titleholder doesn’t face Pacman.

(Terence Crawford, who defends his WBO welterweight title against Amir Khan on April 20, seems to be out of the Pacquiao-Porter-Thurman-Spence mix because he fights for competing Top Rank.)

All that said, let’s assume for a moment that Porter gets all three of his targeted opponents. How does he do against them?


I think he beats the 40-year-old version of Pacquiao, who will have trouble keeping up with Porter’s work rate. I don’t think Porter would win without resistance – Pacquiao can still fight, as he demonstrated by outpointing Broner in January – but I would be surprised if the younger man didn’t win a clear, unanimous decision.

Then, with a big payday and victory in his pocket, let’s say he moves on to the Thurman rematch. I think it would be a 50-50 fight, much like the first one, but I might give Porter a slight edge because of Thurman’s injury-related hiatus from boxing and so-so performance in a majority-decision victory over Josesito Lopez in his comeback fight in January.

So, to recap, victories in the first two fights of his three-fight plan are realistic.

Spence? That’s more unpredictable. Porter has called Spence the “Bogeyman” for a reason – he’s scary. He seems to have a combination of tools that are superior to his rivals. He’s skillful, unusually quick and a particularly strong welterweight, which could be too much for anyone in the division.

One can ask a legitimate question about Spence, though: Who has he fought?

The biggest names on Spence’s resume are probably Kell Brook and Lamont Peterson, who Spence stopped in 2017 and 2018, respectively. Neither was at his best. Brook was coming off his disastrous move to middleweight to face Gennady Golovkin, which ended with Brook’s face broken. Peterson hasn’t won a big fight in many years. And while the gifted Garcia has pound-for-pound status, consensus says that his diminutive size makes him a minimal threat to Spence.

Beyond Brook, Peterson and Garcia? Spence’s resume is relatively thin. Porter arguably would be the stiffest challenge of Spence’s career if they were to meet after Garcia. I would pick Spence to win the fight for the reasons stated above but it wouldn’t be easy, as Porter’s swarming, relentless style can be difficult for anyone to solve.

Remember the problems Jose Luis Castillo and Marcos Maidana gave Floyd Mayweather? That keeps coming to mind when I think of a Porter-Spence matchup.

The bottom line is this: Porter could conceivably land and defeat all three of the opponents he wants. Is it probable? No. Perfects plans often die because of the variables in boxing. Is it possible? Yes.

Porter could retire now and be remembered as one of the better welterweights of the past decade. If he can somehow pull off his trifecta, he would climb onto pound-for-pound lists and be remembered as one of very best of his era.

Michael Rosenthal is the 2018 winner of the Boxing Writers Association of America’s Nat Fleischer Award for excellence in boxing journalism. He has covered boxing in Los Angeles and beyond for almost three decades.

Tags: Shawn Porter image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Curtis Harper on 03-10-2019

''As Porter was announced as the winner, loud jeers could be heard throughout Dignity Health Sports Park, as this was a verdict that will debated for quite a while.'' :puke: Porter's ''style'' is trash. You'd think after a while, [B][U]SOMEONE[/U][/B]…

Comment by Pigeons on 03-10-2019

The best laid plans of mice and men...

Comment by DaBeastO on 03-09-2019

yeah porter you dummy we all saw how well that worked out lol. luckily al gaymon payed off the judges for you

Comment by W1LL on 03-09-2019

[QUOTE=Boxing lives;19571228]Ugas won that. Had Porter hurt down the stretch in the championship rounds. PBC couldn't mess up the rematch with Thurman though. Boxing sucks.[/QUOTE] Was hurt early by bodyshots too.

Comment by FinitoxDinamita on 03-09-2019

[QUOTE=Bjl12;19569167]Yes - you are reading correctly. Blogger Michael Rosenthal compared Errol to Floyd...and those guys fight absolutely NOTHING ALIKE. Good job professional Blogger Michael[/QUOTE] Wsup with you and Michael Rosenthal?

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (42)
Top Headlines Wilder: Why Won't Fury Take Rematch if He Feels He Was Robbed? Argenis Mendez: That Was No Draw, I Beat Anthony Peterson Ryan Garcia Is The Boxing Superstar Of The Digital Era Lamont Peterson: It's Been a Long Career, But Today is The Today Hearn: Fury-Schwarz is Dreadful, Schwarz is Not Even Top 15! Sergey Lipinets Breaks Down, Stops Lamont Peterson in Tenth Lamont Peterson-Sergey Lipinets: LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jamontay Clark Survives Tough Moments, Beats Vernon Brown Anthony Peterson, Argenis Mendez Box To a Split Draw Erik Morales vs. Sergio Martinez Exhibition Clash in Talks Photos: Jarrett Hurd, Julian Williams - Face To Face at Presser Chudinov Stops Nuerlang in Five, Extends W-Streak To Five Peterson vs. Lipinets - LIVE Fights Results From MGM Lamont Peterson-Sergey Lipinets: Stats & Stakes Petr Petrov Stops Hermin Isava in Four Rounds in Spain PBC on FS1 Show Truly A Family Affair For Lamont Peterson Serhii Bohachuk Ready To Begin His 2019 Run at The Avalon Lamont Peterson: Never Felt Like I Was Done After Spence Loss Photos: Jessie Magdaleno Beats Ramos, Dadashev With Big KO Lamont Peterson Feels Refreshed Following Year-Long Ring Break Manny Pacquiao Leaves Spence Off List Of Potential Opponents Photos: Kubrat Pulev, With Horrible Cut, Knocks Dinu Out Photos: Charlie Edwards Dominates Moreno, Retains WBC Belt Photos: Joshua Buatsi, Lawrence Okolie Get Big Knockout Wins Photos: Lewis Ritson Arrives at 140 With Tough Decision Win Wlodarczyk, Cabrera Mioletti, Czerkaszyn Get Weekend Wins Bellew: I'm Not Sure Wilder & Fury Believe They Can Beat Joshua De La Hoya: Canelo Not Afraid of Kovalev, Andre Ward, GGG! Bob Arum: Wilder-Fury Rematch - Not Until February 2020 Julio Cesar Martinez Blasts Out Andrew Selby, Gains WBC Shot Kubrat Pulev Overcomes Severe Cut, Stops Dinu in Seventh Jessie Magdaleno Decisions Rico Ramos Over Ten Maxim Dadashev Flattens Ricky Sismundo in Fourth Round Top Rank on ESPN Undercard Results From Costa Mesa Sam Bowen Continues His Rise With TKO of Jordan McCorry Tyson Fury: I Can't Wait To Face Schwarz, He's Unbeaten & Fresh! Photos: Lamont Peterson, Sergey Lipinets - Ready For Battle Charlie Edwards Easily Outboxes Angel Moreno To Retain Title Nathan Gorman Easily Decisions Kevin Johnson Over Ten Joshua Buatsi Drops Liam Conroy Twice, Stops Him in Third

Latest Active Forum Threads