Malignaggi: Tom Schreck (117-109 For Thurman) Is A Sh*tty Judge

By Keith Idec

NEW YORK – Paulie Malignaggi wasn’t about to pick apart Keith Thurman’s performance Saturday night.

As a fan, the Showtime analyst thoroughly enjoyed Thurman’s 12-round fight against Josesito Lopez from his ringside seat at Barclays Center. Thurman overcame severe trouble during the seventh round to win a majority decision and retained his WBA “super” world welterweight title.

Two judges – Tom Schreck (117-109) and Steve Weisfeld (115-111) – scored the back-and-forth fight for Thurman (29-0, 22 KOs, 1 NC). The other judge, Don Ackerman, scored the fight even (113-113).

thurman-lopez-fight (19)

The thing Malignaggi most disliked about the “PBC on FOX” tripleheader Saturday night was Schreck’s scorecard.

“If you want something to complain about, Tom Schreck had it 117-109,” Malignaggi told a small group of reporters prior to the post-fight press conference. “So, we already know how sh*tty a judge he is, because five years ago I already told you how sh*tty a judge that guy is. So, if you wanna go from that, maybe we can complain about that. The fight was closer than that.”

Malignaggi’s major problem with Schreck, a veteran judge from Albany, New York, scored his 12-round welterweight title fight against Adrien Broner by a wide margin, 117-111, for Broner.

Cincinnati’s Broner won that closely contested bout by split decision in June 2013 at Barclays Center. Two judges scored their fight 115-113 – Glenn Feldman for Broner and Tom Miller for Malignaggi.

“I don’t know, bro,” Malignaggi said. “That guy’s still judging. What did he have for Broner, 117-110 for Broner, when I fought him? I mean, come on. … After a scorecard like that, you shouldn’t get a second chance. Certain scorecards should just get you banned automatically. If you give one scorecard that is that ridiculous, it should. But again, he gave another one tonight, so I don’t know. He’ll probably work again. I don’t know. I don’t run the New York commission, guys.”

The retired Malignaggi often has constructive conversations with judges now that calls fights for Showtime and Sky Sports.

“Some of them complain to me,” Malignaggi said. “Some of them come up to me. I’m friends with certain judges. I don’t fight anymore. We have man-to-man conversations, and it’s fine. We can always agree to disagree, and stuff like that. But I always feel like our job as fighters is more important than their job as judges. They’re gonna go home tonight and sleep good. They don’t give a f***. Tomorrow they worry about the next job they get.

“A fighter goes home, and they’ve gotta assess their career every single, f***ing time. And that’s what pisses me off. And they’ve got the balls to complain. Nah, nah. We complain. We’ve got literal careers change in one night in this sport. Lives change in one night in this sport. So yeah, it makes a bigger difference to us. So, the fighter is more important. I think that’s what gets lost in all this, that the fighter is the most important part.”

Lopez lost for the eighth time in his career Saturday night largely because Thurman out-landed and out-maneuvered the 34-year-old contender for much of their 12-rounder.

Lopez (34-8, 19 KOs, 1 NC), of Riverside, California, hurt Thurman badly during the seventh round. Thurman, of Clearwater, Florida, recovered by the start of the eighth round and landed 130 more punches overall, according to unofficial CompuBox statistics. 

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing. 

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Phill lynott on 01-29-2019

Punch drunk and personal grievances aside, Malignaggi is absolutely correct! See this crap too often. Why cant there be a judging selection between the two fighters camps? Sorta like picking of a jury committee. Where managers can choose judges who…

Comment by Disturbed on 01-28-2019

Judging in boxing is a absurdly hilarious tragedy. Complete joke. I hope things will improve someday in the future. Was just recently reading about Satoshi Shimizu (Japan) vs Magomed Abdulhamidov (Azerbaijan) in olympic boxing. What a scandal, Mamoged was dropped…

Comment by Mike Rotch on 01-28-2019

That was the only good score, Magic Man. I used to like Paulie, but damn he's acting like a bitter woman.

Comment by Dle on 01-28-2019

Then Paulie come out of retirement to show them how it’s done. Get in the ring with Thurman to see how it’ll be scored.

Comment by Freedef on 01-28-2019


Top Headlines
Arum: If Fury Underestimated Wallin, Would've Lost Serrano: Hardy is a Warrior, She Came And Stood For 10 Rounds Wallin: Fury Stole Some Rounds, But A Fair Decision Arum: Fury's Cut Shouldn't Push Back Wilder Rematch Fury's Trainer Hits Back at John Fury's Plea To Fire The Team Nadjib Mohammedi, Firat Arlsan, Mariusz Wach Pick Up Wins Tyson Fury: Doctors Did Fantastic Job, Got Fifty Stitches Jessica McCaskill vs. Erica Farias Rematch on Usyk-Spong Ryan Garcia: This Was Chance To Stand My Ground, Get Respect Otto Wallin's Promoter: We Have A New Top Heavyweight Frank Warren Admits Fury's Cuts Could Delay Wilder Rematch How Billy Walsh is Reviving United States Olympic Hopes Fury: Cut Changed The Fight, I Could Not See Out of That Eye Jaime Munguia Beats Down Patrick Allotey For TKO Win Haney: If I'm So Easy, No-Machenko Should Get Me Out The Way Tyson Fury Suffers Severe Cut, Decisions Otto Wallin Jose Zepeda Wins Big, Decisions Jose Pedraza Emanuel Navarrete Batters, Stops Juan Miguel Elorde Andre Ward Reacts To Tyson Fury's Win, Talks Cut Otto Wallin Reacts To Tyson Fury's Win, Talks Cut Ben Davison Reacts To Tyson Fury's Win, Talks Cut Bob Arum Reacts To Fury's Win, Talks Cut, Slams Hearn Andy Ruiz: After That, No Way Does Fury Beat Me With One Hand Tyson Fury's Father Furious, Wants Him To Dump Team Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - CompuBox Punch Stats Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - Official Scorecards Tyson Fury Overcomes Horrible Cut To Decision Otto Wallin Tyson Fury vs. Otto Wallin - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jaime Munguia Drops Allotey Three Times, Stops Him in Four Emanuel Navarrete Batters, Stops Elorde in Fourth Jose Zepeda Wins Decision, Spoils 140 Debut of Jose Pedraza Jose Pedraza vs. Jose Zepeda - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Carlos Cuadras Edges Cardenas By Majority Decision Fury-Wallin - LIVE Results From Las Vegas Munguia vs. Allotey - LIVE Results From Los Angeles Ben Davison: Fury-Wallin Won't Be A Quick Blowout Warren: We Got Wilder For Fury - Hearn Was Unable For Joshua Fury Eager To Find Out if He's Better Than He Was in 2015 Sunny Edwards Boxes Past Guarneros Over Ten Rounds Parker's Trainer: Otto Wallin is a Safe Fight For Tyson Fury
Latest Forum Threads