Does the Keith Thurman That Beat Garcia & Porter Still Exist?


By Keith Idec

NEW YORK – Keith Thurman strutted to the stage Tuesday afternoon at Gotham Hall, full of confidence and disbelief, as if Manny Pacquiao disrespected him simply by agreeing to their welterweight title fight.

Two years after defeating Danny Garcia for what’s thus far his career-defining victory, Thurman finally appeared to have his swagger back. He oozed self-belief, rather than spouting perplexing responses unbefitting of an undefeated champion.

“I’ve wanted this for too long,” Thurman said. “This is a dream come true. And when you’re a fighter, you fight for everything. You fight for your dreams. For me to get this fight and not fight, it’s not a disservice to this sport. It’s a disservice to the 23 years that I’ve dedicated to this sport. It’s a disservice to [late trainer] Ben Getty, who dedicated 13 years of his life to make me the champion I am today. This fight means more to me than I can express to you in words. So, I will just have to show you guys what it’s all about July 20th.”

Thurman understands skeptics will believe him only if they see him beat Pacquiao impressively. Hearing him speak about it obviously isn’t enough to convince them that the Keith Thurman that beat Shawn Porter and Garcia during an impressive eight-month stretch in 2016 and 2017 still exists.

A rusty Thurman didn’t provide enough evidence January 26 that he’s still the elite welterweight that topped Porter by unanimous decision in one of the best action fights of 2016 and edged Garcia in an extremely competitive welterweight title unification fight in March 2017. He dropped Josesito Lopez in the second round, but Thurman also struggled through the rockiest round of his career in the seventh at Barclays Center in Brooklyn.

Lopez’s left hook hurt Thurman with 1:42 to go in the seventh round. Lopez (36-8, 19 KOs), a huge underdog, followed it up with another damaging left hook, a punishing right hand and several more power punches that sent Thurman into survival mode during his first fight in 22 months.

Thurman, of Clearwater, Florida, showed fortitude by withstanding Lopez’s onslaught and regained control of their fight in the eighth round. Judges Tom Schreck (117-109) and Steve Weisfeld (115-111) scored their fight for Thurman, but he settled for winning a majority decision because judge Don Ackerman scored it a draw (113-113).

“You know, a lot of people believe that you’re only as good as your last fight,” Thurman said. “The only thing was my last fight was a tune-up, you know? I’m a world champion and I showed that when a tough fighter like Josesito Lopez tries to take advantage of a champion like Keith Thurman, off of a 22-month layoff, because that boy came to fight. He always comes to fight, but we know on that night we saw one of the best Josesito Lopez we’ve seen in a long time. And I still defeated the man, OK?”

thurman-garcia-fight (16)

The 30-year-old Thurman indeed left Barclays Center that night with his unblemished record (29-0, 22 KOs, 1 NC) and his WBA “super” welterweight title. But his return from surgery on his right elbow and lingering damage to his left hand created more questions about Thurman than it answered.

There is as much doubt about him entering this FOX Sports Pay-Per-View main event as there is regarding the 40-year-old Pacquiao (61-7-2, 39 KOs).

Beyond the obvious rust he tried to shed versus Lopez, speculation persists within the boxing industry that Thurman’s desire dissipated during his lengthy layoff. The cerebral champion has various interests away from boxing and still doesn’t necessarily sound eager to test himself against Errol Spence Jr. in what would again become an intriguing 147-pound title unification fight if Thurman overcomes Pacquiao and Spence, the IBF champion, beats WBC champ Shawn Porter later this year.

For now, Thurman is fully focused on conquering one of the most legendary boxers of this generation at MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas.

“I knew I wanted to fight Manny Pacquiao,” Thurman said. “I didn’t believe that it would happen. But like we say, man, God is good. Manny’s over here, he’s doing business with us and he signed his contract. So, I’m really grateful. I’m honored to share the ring with him. But I truly do believe that it’s a new era in boxing. Every champion is a new champion that you haven’t heard of. This is a new establishment in the sport. There’s a new heavyweight division and come after July 20th, on July 21st, there will officially be an official, new welterweight division, where you don’t hear the name Floyd Mayweather, where you don’t hear the name Manny Pacquiao, where all you’ll be talking is Keith Thurman, Errol Spence, Terence Crawford, Shawn Porter, Danny Garcia and whoever else that we don’t even know who’s coming up, grinding to be at the top, to compete with the welterweights in the welterweight division today. Manny Pacquiao is the past and I’m gonna make sure of it.”

Thurman promised, too, to make sure to remind his detractors that he’s still the skillful, powerful, tenacious welterweight champion he was when he won the two biggest fights of his career against Garcia and Porter. He has won only one bout by knockout or technical knockout since he stopped Julio Diaz in the third round five years ago, yet Thurman is determined to overpower Pacquiao.

“There’s more to the name ‘One Time,’ ” Thurman said, referring to his nickname. “It’s more than knockouts. I’ve worked really hard to get this one opportunity that I have today. ‘One Time’ is about living a dream of a young man, who was inspired to be a boxer, who won national championships as an amateur. He had a trainer who said, ‘You could be champion of the world.’ ‘One Time’ is about living up to my best legacy. Of course, I wanna be devastating. I wanna be known for my punching power.

“But at the end of the day, when Keith ‘One Time’ Thurman performs, he always puts on a great performance, puts his blood, sweat and tears into the ring. And like I said, I’m really coming this fight. ‘One Time, Sometimes, Once Upon A Time.’ Say what you wanna say about your boy, but Keith ‘One Time’ Thurman’s the truth. There’s a reason I’m undefeated. And I’m proving that.”

The truth about Thurman is, after everything that has happened to him over the past two years, he has at least as much to prove July 20 as Pacquiao.

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by JWHardin on 06-02-2019

[QUOTE=ptek;19786481]All I ever hear on here is this bull**** about Thurman ducking Errol Spence jr, because your a Errol Spencer nut hugger. But those same Errol Spence nut huggers never mention Errol ducking my man T Bud Crawford.[/QUOTE] He's not…

Comment by ptek on 05-31-2019

[QUOTE=JWHardin;19770632]Thurman's "previous injuries" are a joke of the past now. Seriously, arthroscopic surgery on his elbow - out for a year. Bruised hand - out for nearly another year because of that? WTF? He was using it as a way…

Comment by ptek on 05-31-2019

[QUOTE=alexguiness;19770446]Thurman built his reputation as a bogeyman and a lot of people bought into it, including me. But once he got a title his whole approach changed significantly, yes he had injuries but what fighter doesn't? It is clear to…

Comment by ptek on 05-31-2019

[QUOTE=MDPopescu;19770367]............................................ 🦆❓Keith Thurman has refused to guarantee that, should he beat Manny Pacquiao, he will fight Erroll Spence Jr afterwardsIs Thurman ducking Spence?#TWBW— World Boxing Wall (@WorldBoxingWall) May 24, 2019

Comment by ptek on 05-31-2019

[QUOTE=yoshik;19771389]If this blowhard is interested in fighting a legend, fight Spence or Crawford who are in their prime and certain to be legends. Or go back in time and fight Manny at his peak. He would not survive.[/QUOTE] Why are…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (69)
Top Headlines Miguel Vazquez: I'm Supremely Confident I'll Beat Ohara Davies Kal Yafai: Jimenez First - But Then I Need a Massive Fight Next Shakur Stevenson vs. Franklin Manzanilla Set Down For July 13 Acosta May Have To Wait, Soto Could Get Hit With Mandatory Parker: I Know I Can Beat Ruiz A Lot Clearer If We Have Rematch Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Sulecki - Face To Face at State House Photos: Amir Khan Grinds Hard in Camp For Goyat Clash Wladimir Klitschko Rescued After Yacht Catches Fire in Spain Tony Luis Edges Adrian Estrella With Majority Decisions Win Herring Keeping Options Open While Negotiating Mandatory Mikey Garcia's Coach Believes Lomachenko Fight is Still Possible Pacquiao: Thurman Reminds Me of The Miguel Cotto Fight Photos: Pacquiao Continues To Look Fierce in Camp For Thurman BoxingScene Championship Stats, Records: June 2019 Update Gorman: When I Beat Daniel Dubois, What Will He Say Then? Hearn: Anthony Joshua vs. Andy Ruiz Rematch Will Be Massive Lee Selby's Coach: No Issue Fighting Adrien Broner in The U.S. Dawejko Received Death Threats Over Joshua Sparring Rumors Suddenly Violent Rigondeaux Renews Case For 122 Supremacy Adrien Broner vs. Lee Selby in The Works For Later This Year Rey Vargas Expects Fireworks, Vows To Turn Back Tomoki Kameda Andres Gutierrez Edges Tomas Rojas For WBC Regional Title Juan Manuel Marquez Returns To The Ring - As a Promoter McGregor Was Very Pleased That Lobov Defeated Malignaggi Tramaine Williams vs. Neil John Tabanao on Chad Dawson Card Khan: Hopefully Pacquiao Beats Up Thurman, Then We Can Fight! Warren Fires Back at Hearn, Rolls Eyes at Matchroom DAZN Shows Bellew: Tyson Fury Beats Anyone - If It Goes Past 4 Rounds Callum Smith Hopes To Get Clarification on Canelo Possibility Andrade: GGG, Canelo Not The Best Talents at 160 - Just Popular Photos: Amir Khan vs. Neeraj Goyat - Jeddah Press Conference Hughie Fury vs. Sam Peter Set Down For Khan-Goyat Card Dirrell vs. Benavidez Targeted for Wilder-Ortiz Undercard on 9/28 Photos: Jermell Charlo Crushes Jorge Cota With Vicious KO Thurman Touched by Mike Birmingham Hall of Fame Induction Photos: Rigondeaux Goes To War With Ceja, Gets TKO Win Pacquiao-Thurman: No VADA Testing In Place for July 20 PPV Event Rigondeaux: I Wanted To Show Critics I Can Fight at Short Distance Charlo: Harrison is Lucky He Didn't Accept This Fight With Me! Blair Cobbs: I Have The Talent To Beat Anyone at Welterweight

Latest Active Forum Threads