Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Judging The Judges: Kambosos-Bey Scorecard Analysis

The general perception was that the knockdown Mickey Bey suffered in the 10th and final round ultimately cost him the fight versus George Kambosos.

As it turned out, there was never a path to victory for the former lightweight titlist, in the eyes of two judges.

Sydney, Australia’s Kambosos (18-0, 10KOs) survived a stiff test from his most seasoned opponent to date, overcoming a first half scorecard deficit to claim a split decision Saturday evening at Madison Square Garden in New York City. Judges Mark Consentino (New Jersey) and Pasquale Procopio (Canada via Italy) scored the bout 97-92 and 96-93, respectively, for Kambosos, while judge Bernard Bruni (Pennsylvania) turned in the dissenting card in favor of Bey (23-3-1, 11KOs), scoring the contest 95-94 for the former titlist from Cleveland, Ohio. 


As wide were the scores, the three judges were in full agreement on six of the 10 rounds. All three ringside officials had Kambosos sweeping rounds three, four six and 10, with the final round ruled 10-8 with the knockdown call, while agreeing across the board on rounds five and nine in favor of Bey.

None of the judges were more than three rounds apart from one another in terms of consensus scoring.

Consentino and Bruni were the widest apart in their official tallies, though only disagreeing on three rounds. Both scored rounds three, four, six, seven and 10 for Kambosos, while awarding Bey rounds five and nine. 

Round one saw Consentino on his own in awarding the frame to Kambosos, as was the case in round eight.

Bruni’s lone round where he in the minority came in round seven, which he scored for Bey. Consentino and Procopio both awarded it to Kambosos, putting the fight out of reach for Bey with three rounds to go on their respective cards.

Bruni and Procopio only disagreed twice on the night—rounds two and seven. Both frames went to Bey on Bruni’s card and Kambosos on the card of Procopio. The two agreed in awarding rounds one, five eight and nine for Bey, and rounds three, four, six, seven and 10 to Kambosos.

Had Bey remained upright in the 10th and final round and won the frame on Procopio’s card, he’d have escaped with a majority draw. Instead, he leaves New York City with his second loss in his last three fight, spray painted over a 42-month stretch. Bey came up short in a failed bid to regain his lightweight title versus Rances Barthelemy in their June 2016 clash, which also ended in split decision. Similarly, he won the tile in a Sept. 2014 split nod over Miguel Vasquez.

As he’s done throughout the career, Bey once again provided fits for his opponent in the ring as well as those on the other side of the ropes forced to pick a winner. Through varying opinions, he was ultimately not that choice on Saturday.

Jake Donovan is a senior writer for Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback
Top Headlines
As Hurd Returns, Lubin Wants To Restore Order To Crazy Division Joshua: For Legacy and History, The Wilder Fight Will Definitely Happen Alejandra Jimenez: I've Never Used Illegal Drugs - It's a Mistake! Ricardo Mayorga Recovering After Severe Beating By Robbers Alejandra Jimenez Tests Positive For Banned Substances Robles: Andy Ruiz's Father Said They'd Be With Me Until The End! Former 10x National Champion Kahshad Elliott Inks With Split-T Sampson: Josh Taylor-Khonsong Will Land in Great Britain or Scotland Stephen Fulton, Arnold Khegai - Ready For Scrap Jarrett Hurd, Francisco Santana - Set For Battle Danny Garcia, Ivan Redkach - Ready For War at Barclays Fury Trainer Steward: Davison Was Supposed To Be Part of Team Josh Taylor vs. Khonsong: Sampson Boxing Outbids Top Rank Alexis Rocha- Brad Solomon Added To Garcia-Fonseca Card Kell Brook: My Dream Fight? An Errol Spence Rematch! Anthony Fowler Joins Shane McGuigan After Coldwell Split Teixeira vs. Castano: WBO Orders Purse Bid, Jan. 29 In Miami Jason Quigley Calls Out Jaime Munguia For Next Fight Ryan Garcia: I Was Fragile Back In the Day, Now I'm Physically Stronger Fury: Andy Ruiz Should Train With Me If He Wants Titles Back Parker's Trainer Breaks Down The Wilder vs. Fury Rematch Chantelle Cameron Eyes Katie Taylor, Jessica McCaskill in 2020 Jumah Mandatory For Riakporhe After Hyde Win In Wythenshawe Scott Quigg Returns To Trainer Joe Gallagher Ahead Of Carroll Clash Hurd: No Matter What Anybody Says, I Have Best Resume At 154 Whyte vs. Andy Ruiz in Serious Talks, But Povetkin is Frontrunner Joseph Parker vs. Mariusz Wach in Play For Garcia-Vargas Card Marcos Maidana Finds New Motivation For Comeback in 2020 Jason Quigley Puts Away Fernando Marin in Three Rounds Ferdinand Kerobyan Blasts Out Azael Cosio in Two Quigley-Marin on DAZN - LIVE Results From Costa Mesa Danny Garcia: I'd Like To Have 3-4 Fights Per Year - It's Not That Easy Daniel Roman Sees Flaws That He Can Expose in Akhmadaliev Hearn Expects To Finalize Joshua-Pulev in Coming Weeks Ramirez-Postol Title Fight Postponed Due To Wuhan Virus Outbreak Stephen Fulton, Arnold Khegai - Face To Face, Final Presser Jarrett Hurd, Francisco Santana - Face To Face, Final Presser Wilder-Fury Rematch - Full Schedule of Extensive Programming Danny Garcia, Ivan Redkach - Face To Face, Final Presser Shane McGuigan Explains Shock at Josh Taylor's Jump To Top Rank
Latest Forum Threads