If Donaire retired today would he be in the hall of fame?

[raf727]

It is the Hall of Fame not Hall of Achievement.

[IronDanHamza]

you believe that arce & Darchinyan are hall of fame fighters............

ok.

Darchinyan and Arce will most likely go into the HOF.

[IronDanHamza]

i dont believ that sorry i just cant take your word for it ..a guy fighting for a wbU was number 2 in the divison overall? hmmn sounds made up to me..
it's ok that you dont see them guys as a good wins for nonito but to count manfreddy whos inferior compare to those guys as floyd's good wins is just padding the hell out of floyd's resume...

I don't recall if he was #2 but he was defintely in the Top 3.

Here's a link for the end of the year rankings for 1998, where he was #4 (Just after Mayweather beat him)

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...tweight--1990s

[dan_cov]

Is that like, not deserving, or no, he wouldn't make it? It's 2 different levels of delusion. Which of these recent inductees you think are more worthy: Gatti, Hill, Too Sharp Johnson?

I don't think he deserves it though people have seemingly got in for less.

I don't think any of them but out the three, Too sharp Johnson & Virgil Hill, you could probably make a case for but Gatti? Exciting fighter but just no.

There are many I don't feel are really worthy of being in the HOF.