who would have won george vs. george

[Shanus]

If you pick the older Foreman you're saying he's not a top 10 heavyweight IMO.

It was his younger days which made him rank as high as he is in the alltime great heavyweights, he lost to the likes of Tommy Morrison and Evander Holyfield when he was older, and I still rank the younger version of Foreman above both of them.

[hemichromis]

the older foreman was a smarter more focused fighter but the younger foreman is quicker and more powerful

however the older foreman knows how the younger one thinks he would know how he would attack and could therefore counter

[Animal Squabbs]

the older Foreman threw straighter punches too, he wasnt swinging as wild.

[TheGreat1]

I'm going with Younger Foreman.
The older Foreman was able to pace himself more because people where afraid to stand in front of him (except for Holy who beat him) but Young foreman wasn't afraid of anyone. And would have made the older foreman expend way too much energy. By the later rounds older foreman would not have been able to control the fight like he'd want to, and loose a lop sided decision.