Who Wins: Hopkins vs Maskaev at HW!

[Truth]

Look, Im a huge Hopkins fan but I still think that nearly everyone was blind in that Tarver fight. Hopkins was good but that was not nearly the same Tarver at all. He wasnt even close to being himself so it made Hopkins look better then what he really was.

Hopkins would have some skill at HW but he is not a freak athelete like RJ, he hasnt been big for a long time like Toney, and Maskaev is not some slow old bum. He kind of reminds me of Bladomire. Dude has some serious skill. I think he probally knocks Hopkins out.

The thing that pisses me off is as soon as a fighter accomplishes somthing people said he wouldn't accomplish its always taken away by somthing. No one was worried about Tarver's weight going into the fight, Tarver he was ready. Tarver said he was fine and the weight wouldn't be a problem. If he wasn't ready, why did he take the fight? Thats his problem, bottomline is he came and got beat by the better fighter. Styles make fights. Thats why Tarver beat Jones, and thats why Hopkins beat Tarver. I mean did the weight loss affect Tarver? Yeah I could see that. Would it have mattered if he didn't lose that weight? No, since when is Tarver a great fighter? He barley beat Glen Johnson. He had Roy Jones Jr.'s number, but couldn't find Bernards. Bernard, in my opinion would always beat Tarver because he is the better fighter technically.

[Kendo]

Look, Im a huge Hopkins fan but I still think that nearly everyone was blind in that Tarver fight. Hopkins was good but that was not nearly the same Tarver at all. He wasnt even close to being himself so it made Hopkins look better then what he really was.

Hopkins would have some skill at HW but he is not a freak athelete like RJ, he hasnt been big for a long time like Toney, and Maskaev is not some slow old bum. He kind of reminds me of Bladomire. Dude has some serious skill. I think he probally knocks Hopkins out.

You guys are drinking way too much Kool-Aid on that Hopkins victory. I cant believe people honestly cant see that Tarver was not anywhere close to being the guy who fought RJ. He had nothing. I dont care though because RJ was not close to being the same when he fought Tarver, so his win was false to me also. The weight killed both of them and you guys should be able to see that.

Some say that Tarver beat RJ more then once so the weight loss doesnt matter but thats false. The weight kills you for a long time and probally close to forever. Your never the same again. Why the Hell do you think RJ got KO by Glen Johnson. Thats why I said that Lacey would KO Tarver if they fought. I think a pre Hopkins Tarver would kill Lacy but he wont be the same again

you do make a good point but look at it this way. you said that tarver didnt fight the real RJ in any fight i will agree. the first fight he was sapped the second fight he was worked over in the first round and just landed one punch and the third fight when roy fought tarver couldnt answer. ok so how do we know tarver is as good as he is. if tarver would have fought roy before he moved up to HW he would have gotten his butt kicked. so there for this wouldnt be a topic. you cant say hops beat up a bad way tarver. bc how do we know that wasnt the real tarver being man handled by a HEALTHY weight fighter in hops.

[GunStar]

What's up with this poll?? Come on now, no way Bitchkins beats Maskaev, the fight will be over after the first punch Maskaev lands on Bitchnard.

[BmoreBrawler]

yeah tarver looked drugged.

[Undefeated]

Hopkins could win this fight easily.. But will he really do it?

[jai mari078]

No one because this fight is never going to happen. Hopkins is going to stay retired.

[-EX-]

I hope Hopkins stays retired. I think he could win from his smarts and if he can take a punch from a heavyweight.

[drez24]

Hopkins only takes fights he can win, which is why he took the Tarver fight and both Taylor fights, despite what the judges had it at. If he wants to move up to heavyweight he must see something in Oleg he thinks he can expose. or hes just a douche and is doing it for the press.

[beez721]

I havent been on here for awhile so I was seeing have you guys talked about this. I see some Hopkins threads but none about this. Anyways, have you guys already talked about this and do any of you think Hopkins would have a chance?

I feel kind of dumb because I know you guys probally have talked about it but if you havent seen it then here's the article. Im sure you guys havent had a poll though, so this thread shouldnt be a waste
-----------------------------------

Hopkins wants Maskaev!
Former middleweight/light heavyweight king eyes heavyweight division
By Wolfgang Schiffbauer
Bernard Hopkins says he's considering unretiring to face WBC heavyweight champion Oleg Maskaev next June if Maskaev is still champion by then. "The state of the heavyweight divison in America is dead. Bernard Hopkins is the only boxer who can bring it (the heavyweight title) back (to America)," said Hopkins to the New York Daily News. The Executioner retired after becoming the undisputed light heavyweight champion with a victory over Antonio Tarver last June, however Hopkins also said that he will only take the challenge for the heavyweight crown if Mackie Shilstone will help him to bulk up to 200 pounds. Shilstone is a well known fitness guru in the sport, who worked with Hopkins before the Tarver fight and also with Roy Jones Jr. when he moved up to heavyweight and won the WBA belt against John Ruiz in March 2003. According to Hopkins, he would need nine months to get ready for the fight. To make a showdown between both fighters happen, Maskaev has to beat Peter Okhello in December, and most likely mandatory challenger Samuel Peter after this, which could be cause trouble for a clash against the former middleweight king. Of course, it is also not unprecendeted that the WBC would grant Maskaev another voluntary defense against Hopkins and the winner of this bout finally has to face Peter.

maskeav is way too big and strong for hopkins. he'd bully hopkins around the ring and win a very boring decision