The people who think that JAMES TONEY should RETIRE are dead wrong

[Kball15]

James Toney should and will be back.

i personally think he should get a rematch, but he wont because peter will fight maskaev

James Toney looked great in that fight. he took peters shots and ask for more. He held his arms low and wanted to get hit.

and he was countering peter and beating him to the punch, although he did get countered a bit himself. he didnt even fight off the ropes the whole time, and he even was beating peter in the center of the ring!

he should be fighting maskaev next, not peter. i hate watching the guy who lost, but was given the decision, cheer in front of the camera.

[restless_438]

oh absolutely not, James just fought the hardest puncher, in the heaviest division, and took his punches basically with ease... as long as he can't be KO'ed, James can out-box anyone from heavyweight to cruiser IMO

btw, i can't express enough how happy i am to see that the overwhelming majority agrees that Toney won.. glad to see we got some pretty smart people on this board

[BIGTYME]

toney lost

[ferocity]

I thought he won the fight and can beat other heavyweights but i'd rather see him retire, all those heavyweight punchs take its toll on a fighter especially one that started at middleweight.

[Mishra100]

toney lost

lol You will go to ever thread and say this same exact thing won't you.

[-Antonio-]

He took some bad punches and I want to hear how he handles the after effects of them. As far as skill goes, I thnk Toney can box till hes 40-41. A lot of the hard punches he got cought with tonight were because he was trying to hit that left hook from a distance and Peter would counter back with a monster shot. Al Bernstien pointed it out nicely.

Toney's skill is leagues above almost everyone in the heavyweight division. Its really a shame when people like Owen Beck get title shots and Toney gets left in the dust. He would own Maskaev and Valuev. I dont think Valuev would land anything on Toney.

[Grimgash]

Toney got a title shot and blew it plain and simple. Other fighters deserve title shots before him. He got lucky with his draw last time. Really you think Sam Peter is the future of the heavyweight division? Come on, If he beats Wlad Ill say he is one of the greatest boxewrweas pf a;; dimme. Just because middle tgoin to vheavy and beatin someinoe like wlad i s biad asccommplishment.

[DiegoFuego]

I'm a huge Toney fan, but he won't get a shot for a long time. He might as well retire.

[DiegoFuego]

The pieces of **** that hate Toney may have run him out of title contention for good this time. **** them.

[GreatestIam]

I thought he won the fight and can beat other heavyweights but i'd rather see him retire, all those heavyweight punchs take its toll on a fighter especially one that started at middleweight.

Ur wrong TONEY is a greta figther and takes more punches to the gloves and shoulder then face, thats a 10,341 to 19,500 ratio