Would Pacquiao have gone through Mayweather's resume undefeated?

[maenyfresh]

A 20 lb bigger Cotto and a 25lb bigger Oscar are going to give him sht loads of problems you better believe that, so many gloss over the weight with these guys its just unreal, there is a reason Manny wanted nothing to do with Cotto at 154 even though he called him out but one caveat no CW no fight, I know why and so does Manny.

Nah Manny's style is all wrong for Cotto and Oscar irrespective of what weight it is, let's not kid ourselves here. The A side will always try and get the best advantage possible (also mind game thing), doesn't mean Manny could not beat them above 147. E.g. Floyd brought Canelo down to 152 and was overweight for Marquez but that does not mean that he would not have beat Canelo at 154 and Marquez at the initial agreed weight.

[megas30]

Does Pac beat Castillo, Corrales, Hernandez, etc at 130-135?

Does he beat Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, etc at 140-147?

Does he beat Marquez from 2009 at 146?

Does he beat Oscar and Cotto at 154?

Does he beat 23yo Canelo at 152?

Does he beat Maidana in 2014?

He already lost to Marquez and no way he's beating Canelo.

[blowblow]

definitely yes. .see how pac dominated their common opponents.. zab judah gave floyd a boxing lesson. a southpaw that knockdown floyd and gave him a hard time.. even floyd's cornermen were angry coz their boy can't do shlt against judah.

[The Big Dunn]

definitely yes. .see how pac dominated their common opponents.. zab judah gave floyd a boxing lesson. a southpaw that knockdown floyd and gave him a hard time.. even floyd's cornermen were angry coz their boy can't do shlt against judah.

Pac dominated JMM?

Manny can’t go through Floyd’s resume undefeated because he has a draw and a loss to a guy Floyd beat.

[blowblow]

Pac dominated JMM?

Manny can’t go through Floyd’s resume undefeated because he has a draw and a loss to a guy Floyd beat.

floyd lost to castillo, DLH, etc. stupld people wll think he won that gift wins.

[The Big Dunn]

floyd lost to castillo, DLH, etc. stupld people wll think he won that gift wins.

Floyd beat both of them. You don’t feel he did because you like Manny. Cool. Not what this thread is about.

To this thread, if you honestly feel he did lose these fights, you know in your heart Manny would lose to those men at the same point, if for no other reason than the size differential.

Either way you can’t answer this question yes, like you did, and be taken seriously in any way given Manny’s draw and ko loss to JMM.

You come off as angry and ashamed that Manny could never beat JMM as decisively in 4 tried as Floyd did in 1.

[Nicamex]

Manny couldn't even go through his own resume undefeated

[blowblow]

Floyd beat both of them. You don’t feel he did because you like Manny. Cool. Not what this thread is about.

To this thread, if you honestly feel he did lose these fights, you know in your heart Manny would lose to those men at the same point, if for no other reason than the size differential.

Either way you can’t answer this question yes, like you did, and be taken seriously in any way given Manny’s draw and ko loss to JMM.

You come off as angry and ashamed that Manny could never beat JMM as decisively in 4 tried as Floyd did in 1.

size doesn't matter. common logic that always goes around is A > B and B > C doesn't mean A > C.. stupd people believe that A>C

and for JMM, floyd didn't fight JMM multiple times so you can't compare that. floyd is always afraid of the rematch.. how many does he have?

[The Big Dunn]

size doesn't matter. common logic that always goes around is A > B and B > C doesn't mean A > C.. stupd people believe that A>C

and for JMM, floyd didn't fight JMM multiple times so you can't compare that. floyd is always afraid of the rematch.. how many does he have?

What? How are you that bad at math?

The proper equation is A>B and A>C and B>=C.

Man you can’t be taken seriously.

[GhostofDempsey]

Of course he does.