Who has had more disappointing career Gary Rusell, Keith Thurman or Demetrius Andrade

[Blue54]

Thurman has the better resume and wins of the 3 but the layoffs are ridiculous and he lost to a past prime Pacquiao.

Andrade has some decent wins in 3 decent wins in Vanes, Culcay, and Sulecki but he has been fighting world level since 2013 and never fought a top 5 ranked in his divisions.

Russell fights literally once a year for the past 5 years now. He has some decent wins but not one real career defining victory past prime Gonzalez or Joseph Diaz maybe.
Dude stays calling for super fights but barely gets in the ring.

All 3 had hype around them and all 3 did end up becoming world champions but their championship reigns haven’t live up to the hype.

[Beercules]

Russell by far.

[TheBoxGod]

Thurman did very well for himself than the other 2, Gary Russel jr just lets his spark dies out everytime he gets soemthing going, and andrade still got alot of time with no damage.

So..... Russel Jr.

[Mammoth]

Thurman had a good career wth

[Rip Chudd]

Wow, that's a tough decision in picking between GRJ and Andrade. Both wasting away

[whollisboxing]

Thurman has the better resume and wins of the 3 but the layoffs are ridiculous and he lost to a past prime Pacquiao.

Andrade has some decent wins in 3 decent wins in Vanes, Culcay, and Sulecki but he has been fighting world level since 2013 and never fought a top 5 ranked in his divisions.

Russell fights literally once a year for the past 5 years now. He has some decent wins but not one real career defining victory past prime Gonzalez or Joseph Diaz maybe.
Dude stays calling for super fights but barely gets in the ring.

All 3 had hype around them and all 3 did end up becoming world champions but their championship reigns haven’t live up to the hype.

Thurman has had layoffs but his run from 2013-2017 was good. He has the better resume as you said because he faced top opposition

Andrade has been boxed out in a sense but at least he was signed to fight Billy Joe Saunders before Saunders failed his drug test.

Russell Jr. has tremendous talent that he only displays once a year against fairly non-descript opposition. He hasn't had a big fight since Loma in 2014 so I think his career has been most disappointing so far.

[Shadoww702]

Russell by far.

That's Groundhog Gary!

[Ry92]

Thurman 147 resume porter garcia pacquiao better than anything crawford come close to. 3 top 10 opps vs zero. So outside being the most injury prone boxer rivaled only to beterbiev. (Theyre the grant hill andrew luck of boxing. Talented but stay hurt to the point there prime been robbed by unlimited injuries. Gary russell n andrade on the other hand no excuses. Has andrade even fought anyone dude makes crawford selection of opps look legit. I get the name of the game get a belt milk it dont fight a soul ranked unless huge $ to compensate the risk yet andrade should be stripped of title similar to crawford if fights 1 more bum or shot fighter next. Atleast take a risk 1 out of 4 fights fight your bums 3 fights then fight a garcia if crawford or fight sergey if andrade. Andrade doesnt even have david lemieux on record literally everyone worth it has him on resume . enough sad bout the bum andrade

[_Rexy_]

Thurman has had a good career with injuries. Gary had his brain broken by Loma and now only fights once a year so he doesn't get stripped of his title, and Andrade fights people nobody has ever heard of while five people watch.

[JakeTheBoxer]

Thurman has very respectable career. What the hell are you talking about?

Thurman is much more proven welterweight than Crawford for example.