Official bad scorecard thread 2021.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Same as last year, gonna make a thread where we can log and track and log and con****uous scorecards that appear so often in boxing.

Despite the limited schedule in 2020, we still had 53 dodgy scorecards across the year, with various judges reoffending several times.

https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/s...d.php?t=837876

As always post any card from any fight you felt was unjust, unfair etc.

1. Steve Gray scoring Barrett-Martinez 118-111 to Barrett.

2. Robert Williams scoring Barrett-Martinez 118-111 to Barrett.

3. Howard Foster scoring Barrett-Martinez 116-113 to Barrett.

4. John Latham scoring Valenzuela-Davies 94-94 a draw.

5. Tom Carusone scoring Broner-Santiago 116-111 to Broner.

6. Peter Hary scoring Broner-Santiago 117-110 to Broner.

7. Greg Burgess scoring Parker-Fa 119-109 to Parker.

8. Carlos Sucre scoring Gonzalez-Estrada 117-111 to Estrada.

9. Marcus McDonnell scoring Adeleye-Sokolowski 58-57 to Adeleye.

10. Steve Gray scoring Edwards-Mthalane 118-111 to Edwards.

11. Bob Williams scoring Edwards-Mthalane 120-108 to Edwards.

12. Grzegorz Molenda scoring Parker-Chisora 116-111 to Parker.

13. Steve Gray scoring Bivol-Richards 115-114 to Bivol.

14. Yury Koptsev scoring Bivol-Richards 115-113 to Bivol.

15. Viktor Fesechko scoring Kurbanov-Smith 117-112 to Kurbanov.

16. Don Griffin scoring Cissokho-Conway 97-92 to Conway.

17. Fabian Guggenheim scoring Eggington-Molina 119-109 to Eggington.

18. John Rupert scoring Hurd-Arias 95-94 to Hurd.

19. Eva Zaragoza scoring Leo-Alameda 98-92 to Leo.

20. Nelson Vazquez scoring Charlo-Castano 117-111 to Charlo.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Thoughts on the Garcia-Campbell scorecards?

The 3 judges had it 58-56, 58-55, 58-55 all to Garcia.

I personally had it 57-56 to Campbell at the time of the knockout.

[famicommander]

Thoughts on the Garcia-Campbell scorecards?

The 3 judges had it 58-56, 58-55, 58-55 all to Garcia.

I personally had it 57-56 to Campbell at the time of the knockout.

I only gave Campbell the knockdown round and maybe one other.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

I only gave Campbell the knockdown round and maybe one other.

The other two I gave him where both competitive rounds tbf.

[deathofaclown]

I think I gave Campbell 2 rounds, but can see an argument for only giving him the knockdown round.

The only really shady thing about the scorecard was one judge not giving the 10-8 round.

[moochi]

Turn the audio off and you'll give more rounds to Campbell. Garcia was hitting a lot of leather whilst Campbell was actually landing a few shots in between.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Turn the audio off and you'll give more rounds to Campbell. Garcia was hitting a lot of leather whilst Campbell was actually landing a few shots in between.

That’s why I had him in front. Felt he was landing the cleaner shots. The commentary on DAZN is always horrendous. Kenny and Mannix are absolutely horrible.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

The UK is now the worst place in the world to box in the away corner. The BBBofC are a disgrace for continually employing these crooks and never investigating their clear incompetence.

As a British boxing fan I’m embarrassed. Fighters are getting robbed regularly, it’s completely unacceptable.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Wouldn’t surprise me if those stooges had Warrington up at the time of the KO if the cards are ever released.

[YoungManRumble]

Let's hope this thread has less posts/pages then last years!

Minor typo in the original post saying 2021 for last year btw.