Comments Thread For: Canelo: Those Who Know More About Boxing - Consider Me P4P Best

[chepboxingking]

I'm not gonna lie, he has some debatable decisions where he could've lost, I thought GGG beat him clearly the 1st fight and I thought Lara barely beat him, still I do think that he has earned the #1 spot by beating the most champions and the best fighters out there.

Don't get me wrong, in my book he still has business pending with Charlo and Bivol aside all the 168 titilists but based on his resume he will look to fight the best guys out there.

Eye test tells me Bud is a more complete fighter, I think he's got a little more dimensions to his game but the huge problem i got with him is that he has not fought anyone of notice, best wins are Gamboa and Postol.

Inoue has beat some solid guys in spectacular fashion but to me he needs to fight a Rigo caliber guy or unify the whole division to claim that spot.

My list:

1 Canelo
2 Crawford
3 Inoue
4 Spence
5 Charlo (Jermell)

Jermell over Jamal? I personally think they're both top 10, but I rank Jamal higher

[chepboxingking]

Alvared is the face of boxing hands down but he absolutely has to fight Jermall Charlo. No ducking around that fight in 2021🥊

Agree. Canelo seems to want only title fights from here on out. If he goes back down to 160, no doubt he'll face Charlo

[Bigchip]

And Those Who Are REAL About Boxing - Consider you a drug cheat!

[ShoulderRoll]

Until you start getting into nuances.

Feel free to name a fighter that you think has a better combination of "eye test" skills PLUS resume.

[MrShakeAndBake]

unmm Bud Crawford is P4P , clenbuterol boy...

[Roberto Vasquez]

Got to be honest I know about boxing but couldn't care less about P4P. It's just a fun thing for fans to think about. Canelo is def one of the greatest boxers around just now.

[Roberto Vasquez]

I'm not gonna lie, he has some debatable decisions where he could've lost, I thought GGG beat him clearly the 1st fight and I thought Lara barely beat him, still I do think that he has earned the #1 spot by beating the most champions and the best fighters out there.

Don't get me wrong, in my book he still has business pending with Charlo and Bivol aside all the 168 titilists but based on his resume he will look to fight the best guys out there.

Eye test tells me Bud is a more complete fighter, I think he's got a little more dimensions to his game but the huge problem i got with him is that he has not fought anyone of notice, best wins are Gamboa and Postol.

Inoue has beat some solid guys in spectacular fashion but to me he needs to fight a Rigo caliber guy or unify the whole division to claim that spot.

My list:

1 Canelo
2 Crawford
3 Inoue
4 Spence
5 Charlo (Jermell)

That list is hilarious. Canelo is the only one who is actually 100% proven. Crawford fighting faded fighters in Khan and Brook. Spence did the same with Brook and only just fought someone decent in Garcia. Doesn't take much to get on your list!

[TheBoxGod]

Its not even debatable, its not. Canelo is P4P#1.

[Rahat]

Canelo takes that p4p spot with ease. Crawford ain't fought one live body so I dont have him numbe two I think Errol Spence has earned that spot.

[Ry92]

Theres a reason i dont rate crawford number 1 i feel u have to face competition thats ranked. If your out there smoking unranked oponents with a belt (terence crawford at 147 theyve been non but a bunch welter rocky fieldings lol) that shouldnt count. Canelo has multi ? Marks themselves both GGG fights especially the first plus add in the lara fight. Yet between lara cotto ggg callum smith kovalov trout and jacobs dude actually fights top ranked competion ofcourse its take 2 easy fights for 1 hard fight yet still fighting n convincingly winning 97% of em vs top ranked opposition unlike crawford . lol because lomanchanko fought teflo n luke campbell i theyre slightly ahead of crawford. It should be bout quality not quantitiy .