Who Did Better VS Floyd: Mosley or manny

[boliodogs]

I think Manny won 4 rounds and Mosley won 1 round in which he staggered Mayweather badly. Pac did better in my opinion.

[ralex]

Mosley was the better fight just for the entertainment of almost KO Floyd. That was fun

[Luilun]

Some thought Pacquaio won like Holyfield. Floyd Sr told Floyd you’re fighting scared no one thought Mosley won he won round 2 that was it he got his head snap back like 50 times . All Floyd did against Pacquaio was move and hold

[djtmal]

manny won 2 to 3 rounds with 4 and 6 certainly being his.

Mosley won 2 rounds also and hurt Floyd the most in his career

Mosley end up getting whooped. manny got a lesson

Really what difference does it make. Both guys were well out of their primes, and don't represent Floyd's best wins by a longshot.

[IronDanHamza]

both fights were boring, mayweather just running around, refusing to engage properly and nicking rounds via a few jabs. he didnt do any damage to either guy, they could have done 30 rounds.

From this post I find it incredibly hard to believe you’ve even watched Mayweather vs Mosley considering the way you’ve described it there is nothing at all similar to what actually happened in that fight.

[IronDanHamza]

Really what difference does it make. Both guys were well out of their primes, and don't represent Floyd's best wins by a longshot.

Why were you so desperate for Floyd to fight Mosley in 2010 if you felt this way?

[djtmal]

Why were you so desperate for Floyd to fight Mosley in 2010 if you felt this way?

I am just keeping it a buck. We had already seen Mosley get thrashed by Forrest and Winky when he was closer to his prime. Tough fights with Cotto and Vargas.
It finally took for Shane to get in the ring and call Floyd out for Floyd to finally grow a pair and make the fight, and it still took Floyd a year and a half to fight a pushing 40 Shane who had seen better days.
I mean, is this what you call top notch boxing because I certainly don't, but I gotta realize I am talking to a Floyd boy who makes excuses for this kind of thing.

[IronDanHamza]

I am just keeping it a buck. We had already seen Mosley get thrashed by Forrest and Winky when he was closer to his prime. Tough fights with Cotto and Vargas.
It finally took for Shane to get in the ring and call Floyd out for Floyd to finally grow a pair and make the fight, and it still took Floyd a year and a half to fight a pushing 40 Shane who had seen better days.
I mean, is this what you call top notch boxing because I certainly don't, but I gotta realize I am talking to a Floyd boy who makes excuses for this kind of thing.

Ok so why were you so desperate to see it at the time then?

Did you not know this information at the time?

[djtmal]

Ok so why were you so desperate to see it at the time then?

Did you not know this information at the time?

I answered your question. You don't like the answer not my problem.
Now answer mine. Is two guys one past prime, another way past prime and shopworn top notch boxing. Does beating a pushing 40 Shane Mosley represent Floyd's best win

[tophat1]

Mosley by far. Very easy to look back and reflect that Manny picked up slightly more rounds but watching both live Floyd never looked like he wasn't on control of the Manny fight but watching the Mosley fight there was a real feeling Floyd could be on his way to a loss after Mosley buzzed him ( he turned it around fast to be fair tho)