Do the Charlo Twins deserve PFP Status

[Squ□redCircle34]

Jermell is #10 on my pound for pound list and Jermall is #14 so both are in the top 15 which shows how far they’ve come!

They’re getting more respect these days and both are good for boxing!

Hopefully Castaņo can knock off Teixera so we can get a Mell Charlo vs Castaņo for all the belts next year!

Canelo vs Mall Charlo is now one of the biggest fights in boxing!

[QueensburyRules]

I can say that I'm a Jermell and Jermall Charlo fan, but do they deserve to be in pfp top 10.

Notable Wins for mell:

-Robbery then knock out of Tony Harrison

-Jeison Rosario (who knocked out Julian Williams but who also got knocked out by Nathaniel Gallimore)

-Past Prime Austin Trout

-Glass chin Erickson Lubin who was recently almost knocked out by terrell "no power" gausha

-And if you really wanted to boost his resume, John Jackson who he won the vacant WBC title fighting

Notable Wins for mall:

-pre-chinny Julian Williams

-Cornelius Bundrage

-Past prime Austin Trout

-Struggle fight against little but highly skilled Matt Korobov

-And recently a shut-out performance against Sergiy Derevyanchenko


I think mell should be pfp based solely on accomplishments, that being he is a 3 or 4 belt champ, but he hasn't yet fought a fighter that I thought could give him a REAL TEST (GGG to Canelo etc).

Simply put, I don't think Jermall has done enough to become pfp top 10


Tried making this post too many times

- -Lessee, smell and small PPV that aleady bombed once?

Only cretins to pay for this would be on an ******uous porrn promotion.

In short, the sordid half of this forum!

[richardt]

If they keep winning, they can't be denied. But the way to be sure is to be the king of their division. Mall would only need to beat either Andrade or Billy Ho. Even a win over Andrade or Billy Hoe should clearly get him at or near or in the top 10. Even though Canelo is out there, if Mall and Canelo don't hook up, Mal can still be a top 10 PFP. And Mell could fight Fundora or Hurd. Mell just tormented Rosario which is a solid win which should get him closer. I don't think Harrison won that first fight so I dont count that, and he took out Harrison after that.

If they accomplish that, its hard to deny them a ranking in the top 10 because they are solid, always in top shape, perform extremely well.

[mxtali]

More proof that resumes don't mean sh_t because whether a fighter counts as a credible win or not is solely up to the individual and whether they feel like praising a fighter they like or denigrating a fighter they don't like. "The legendary Matt Korobov. The mythical Tony Harrison. The Godlike David Lemieux. The Herculean, undefeated Dominic Wade!" lol.

Jermall is close, he did style on D-chenko unlike Jacobs and GGG, but we'll see. The problem is the p4p top ten is very hard to crack as there are multiple lineal, unified and undefeated champions who have actually beat the best in their division.

Yeah anytime someone wants to talk down a resume they can nitpick any little thing to make it look bad. You can find an asterisk on every top fighters wins. And if you want to talk it up then there’s ways to do that too.

[richardt]

Jermell is #10 on my pound for pound list and Jermall is #14 so both are in the top 15 which shows how far they’ve come!

They’re getting more respect these days and both are good for boxing!

Hopefully Castaņo can knock off Teixera so we can get a Mell Charlo vs Castaņo for all the belts next year!

Canelo vs Mall Charlo is now one of the biggest fights in boxing!

Mell and Mall cannot be denied for much longer. I dont think Harrison beat Mell the first fight and Mell ended that rivalry with a convincing stoppage. Mall had the close one with Korobov but Korobov didn't do himself any favors for a potential rematch with his performance (draw) against Aleem and then an injury against Eubank Jr didn't help his cause. So now it is onward and upward for the Mell and Mall.

[Luilun]

A Big No, they don't have enough name fighters under their belt

[techliam]

Why group them together?

Jermell has far eclipsed his brother in terms of achievements

I don’t think he is far off P4P recognition

[sicko]

Jermell Charlo ABSOLUTELY!


We have to put the childish Garbage "I Hate The Guy!" trash aside and give credit when a fighter earns it and I think Jermell properly EARNED his spot and Jermell earned his spot on a Top 10 P4P Rankings but Unifying the Divisions and is 1 Title away from being Undisputed.

So yes he is a Top 10-15 P4P Fighter and if he is able to get the WBO, then just like Crawford and just like Usyk, you have to jump him up in the P4P Rankings and give him his due

People are denying them because they don't like them but that is NOT how Boxing Works and that is not how a P4P Ranking Works.

P4P is not a Popularity ranking of 10 Guys you have the biggest Man Crush On!

[-DSG-]

Jermell yes jermall no.

[LacedUp]

hell fkn no