"Gallo" Estrada should be ranked higher than Inoue P4P

[rickJen]

Here we go again. Eye test doe. Should rank higher doe.
Exactly what happened to Wilder passing the eye test vs Ortiz,
and many other similar ones passing the eye test doe.
Kills me.

[ShoulderRoll]

Here we go again. Eye test doe. Should rank higher doe.
Exactly what happened to Wilder passing the eye test vs Ortiz,
and many other similar ones passing the eye test doe.
Kills me.

P4P does consist of the eye test, in terms of the skills you can see a fighter demonstrate.

But it also should consist of resume. Who did you display skills against?

Just old Nonito? Or prime Chocolatito and Rungvisai?

[Build That Wall]

You’re not wrong that they haven’t fought him. But that is because he is a problem.

Has a good case to be ranked top 10 p4p but I wouldn’t put him ahead of Inoue .

They all ducked him

[Madison Boxing]

ive not seen inoue in with a world level fighter yet, his opposition has been atrocious. he sure didnt look like a 'monster' to me when he almost lost to a washed up, 10 years past prime donaire either.

[sicko]

He is Top 10 P4P For sure I been Posting this for awhile but sadly not many...not even so called Boxing Experts and Reporters seems to give a SH^T about the Smaller Divisions so him as well as Julio Cesar Martinez, Nordine Ouabaali, John Riel Casimero, Kazuto Ioka guys like that are often times left off of many P4P Rankings

[QueensburyRules]

They both pass the eye test.

But one has a significantly better resume in my opinion.

- -Recent eye test claims the bell rang 24 Sec early to keep Quadras from knocking out Estrada the rd before Quadras was stopped.

Sounds like a fair and equitable rematch is in order first, but that ain't the way U and boxing operate.

Big $ hyping up Choco in his comeback. Follow the $...

[baroidi]

Estrada should rank higher than Inoue and Crawford.

[ShoulderRoll]

They all ducked him

Chocolatito, Estrada, Sor Rungvisai, and Cuadras have all gone through hell fighting each other multiple times.

Inoue left their weight class without facing a single one of them.

[kidbazooka]

I agree I would put Estrada behind only canelo and Teo and maybe Manny but’s that’s it.

[Rick Taylor]

41-3, 28 KO's.

He has the skills and boxing IQ, as he has shown the versatility to be a smart counterpuncher or also go to war if that is needed.

But more importantly he has proven this against a high level of opposition. Having had fights with Roman Gonzalez, Sor Rungvisai, and Carlos Cuadras.

Naoya Inoue was in the same division with all these guys yet managed to fight none of them.

Am I wrong?

estrada looked terrible last night tbh.
hes usually a lot better. he may be on the slide.