Greater fighter: Juan Manuel Marquez or Bernard Hopkins?

[champion4ever]

Hands down, it's Bernard Hopkins. To become the oldest boxing champion in history at age 46 and 48 is just unbelievable and unremarkable.

[pretty ste]

Bernard hopkins all day

[Squ□redCircle34]

Hopkins FTW!!!

[Lomasexual]

JMM was brilliant, and maximum respect to him. I think Bhop has to win this one though. His record breaking reign as middleweight champion and his astonishing longevity just push him a bit further in this comparison.

[kidbazooka]

Marquez ko of Manny is greater than anything Hopkins ever did.

Marquez doesn’t get knocked out the ring.

[PRINCEKOOL]

Bernard Hopkins, was more dominant as a champion 'Marquez maybe has the better single win, but overall? Hopkins has a higher number of great wins etc'.

[11player]

Two outstanding fighters, ATGs, legends.

Much respect and admiration to both, as a boxing fan.

[hugh grant]

Hopkins. Even though jmm got the best win. Goes to show you can't make a career with 1,2 or even 3 or 4 great wins. It's your whole career.
That's why SRL isn't as great as pac

[Mighty_Windir]

I love Marquez.

Bhop takes this one

[GhostofDempsey]

JMM, he fought better opposition at their best. Hopkins padded his record against journeymen and smaller fighters coming up.