Does Floyd resume hold up against the greats?

[ironmike2012]

The names are great, but most were fought at the right time and/or weight, green catchweight Canelo, old Oscar, small JMM, or 140 champ Hatton at 147.
Then there are the fights he lost, Castillo or Maidana.
Don't forget the fighters he ducked, Margarito or Williams.
50-0 is nice, but he rarely took real chances, he fought washed up Berto, instead of other top fighters.
You could pick apart most of his fights, resume at 147 is okay, not great.

[Larry the boss]

JMM has a better resume and was higher rated p4p fighter than any of those fighters.

Corrales, Castillo shouldn't even be mentioned with the rest.

his resume really is not that deep when you look at it

[daggum]

well lets see he has prime baldomir. you think duran or hearns would hang with baldy?

[daggum]

JMM has a better resume and was higher rated p4p fighter than any of those fighters.

Corrales, Castillo shouldn't even be mentioned with the rest.

jmm was moving up 2 divisions thats trash. corrale and castillo arent as good but they were at least in the same division and we also know floyd was cheating wtih his tue's in his "comeback" so you gotta put an asterik on all those fights astros style