Pac's Career Put Into Perspective

[kidbazooka]

I’m no Pac fanboy I cheered against him during his hey day because he beat most of my favorite fighters Of the time.

But are you saying Pac IS NOT a great fighter????

Or just his WW run?

[BodyBagz]

I’m no Pac fanboy I cheered against him during his hey day because he beat most of my favorite fighters Of the time.

But are you saying Pac IS NOT a great fighter????

Or just his WW run?

You say you're not a Pac fanboy yet you so very enthusiastically voted Pac yes, May nope in that silly little ''Top 10 ATG list'' thread.

Definitely his WW career and most of his early ''fights''. How many no names did he fight before finally finding a known guy ?

There's room for every fighter to be criticized......except 2 -
Pac and Fury. With resumes like theirs (mostly Fury of course)?!?!?!

WTF

[kidbazooka]

You say you're not a Pac fanboy yet you so very enthusiastically voted Pac yes, May nope in that silly little ''Top 10 ATG list'' thread.

Definitely his WW career and most of his early ''fights''. How many no names did he fight before finally finding a known guy ?

There's room for every fighter to be criticized......except 2 -
Pac and Fury. With resumes like theirs (mostly Fury of course)?!?!?!

WTF

Oh I agree with you 100% with Fury he doesn’t even belong in the same sentence as Manny.

Here’s the thing bro by discrediting Manny at WW or overall your discrediting Floyd’s best win. No other fighter on Floyd’s resume is as accomplished or great as Manny. Not corralles, not gatti, not past his prime Oscar, not Judah, not hatton, not Mosley, not maidana, not a 22 yr old green canelo not Berto NON of them.

So if I was a Floyd fanboy I would be praising Manny left n right instead of knocking him because the more you bash Manny you end up taking away Floyd’s best win.

What 40 yr old Manny did in beating a young in his prime undefeated champ in Thurman was very very impressive. Manny beat a legit ww champ he’s not out there fighting 20 yr old 126lb boys.

[BodyBagz]

Oh I agree with you 100% with Fury he doesn’t even belong in the same sentence as Manny.

Here’s the thing bro by discrediting Manny at WW or overall your discrediting Floyd’s best win. No other fighter on Floyd’s resume is as accomplished or great as Manny.

So if I was a Floyd fanboy I would be praising Manny left n right instead of knocking him because the more you bash Manny you end up taking away Floyd’s best win.

What 40 yr old Manny did in beating a young in his prime undefeated champ in Thurman was very very impressive. Manny beat a legit we champ he’s not out there fighting 20 yr old 126lb boys.

Lucas, Rios, Broner, Margarito, Vargas, Clottey, HORN, Bradley 3x, Algieri, The worst versions of DLH, Cotto and Mosley.....

Pac's WW career is a joke. Unless a person is a fanboy.

[kidbazooka]

Lucas, Rios, Broner, Margarito, Vargas, Clottey, HORN, Bradley 3x, Algieri, The worst versions of DLH, Cotto and Mosley.....

Pac's WW career is a joke. Unless a person is a fanboy.

That’s fine it’s your opinion I’m sure most will disagree but no biggie. Like I said then Floyd’s ww run is not impressive either because his best win is against a “joke” according to you.

But do you aknowledge Manny is an all time great?

Oh and yes I’m no manny fanboy but I do rank Manny ahead of Floyd just like I rank SRR ahead of Lamotta despite losing to him, manny like SRR went on to accomplishe more than Floyd.

[BodyBagz]

Gatti > Lucas
Berto > Rios
Maidana > Broner
Baldomir > Clottey

[kidbazooka]

Gatti > Lucas
Berto > Rios
Maidana > Broner
Baldomir > Clottey

All of those guys were jokes at ww so not a good look for either guy there.

Your left with

Old Oscar
Cotto
Mosley
Judah

Manny at ww has
Thurman
Bradley 2x
Old Oscar too
Cotto too
Mosley

So very similar opponents as there best wins but who beat them in more impressive fashion.

See you have to give Manny his dues and by doing so all of a sudden Floyd’s WW resume looks waaaaay more impressive with that Manny win alone.

Think about it bro.

[hugh grant]

All of those guys were jokes at ww so not a good look for either guy there.

Your left with

Old Oscar
Cotto
Mosley
Judah

Manny at ww has
Thurman
Bradley 2x
Old Oscar too
Cotto too
Mosley

So very similar opponents as there best wins but who beat them in more impressive fashion.

See you have to give Manny his dues and by doing so all of a sudden Floyd’s WW resume looks waaaaay more impressive with that Manny win alone.

Think about it bro.

Any historian worth his salt will have Pac down as a better Ww with stronger more depth resume.
That's why Pac is top 6 all time. Pac s ww resume is better than.natural ww, i.e. Cotto, spence, thurman guys who campaigned there their whole career almost.

[BodyBagz]

That’s fine it’s your opinion I’m sure most will disagree but no biggie. Like I said then Floyd’s ww run is not impressive either because his best win is against a “joke” according to you.

But do you aknowledge Manny is an all time great?

Oh and yes I’m no manny fanboy but I do rank Manny ahead of Floyd just like I rank SRR ahead of Lamotta despite losing to him, manny like SRR went on to accomplishe more than Floyd.

Pac had an easier road to whatever it is he accomplished.
I asked you how many fights did Pac have before he fought a legit guy ?

All of those guys were jokes at ww so not a good look for either guy there.

Your left with

Old Oscar
Cotto
Mosley
Judah

Manny at ww has
Thurman
Bradley 2x
Old Oscar too
Cotto too
Mosley

So very similar opponents as there best wins but who beat them in more impressive fashion.

See you have to give Manny his dues and by doing so all of a sudden Floyd’s WW resume looks waaaaay more impressive with that Manny win alone.

Think about it bro.

Once again
May beat the better versions of DLH, Cotto and SSM.
Pac has more fights but not better wins.

Any historian worth his salt will have Pac down as a better Ww with stronger more depth resume.
That's why Pac is top 6 all time. Pac s ww resume is better than.natural ww, i.e. Cotto, spence, thurman guys who campaigned there their whole career almost.

Name those 8 div champs Pac took belts from or beat it.

[Roadblock]

Oh I agree with you 100% with Fury he doesn’t even belong in the same sentence as Manny.

Here’s the thing bro by discrediting Manny at WW or overall your discrediting Floyd’s best win. No other fighter on Floyd’s resume is as accomplished or great as Manny. Not corralles, not gatti, not past his prime Oscar, not Judah, not hatton, not Mosley, not maidana, not a 22 yr old green canelo not Berto NON of them.

So if I was a Floyd fanboy I would be praising Manny left n right instead of knocking him because the more you bash Manny you end up taking away Floyd’s best win.

What 40 yr old Manny did in beating a young in his prime undefeated champ in Thurman was very very impressive. Manny beat a legit ww champ he’s not out there fighting 20 yr old 126lb boys.

Floyds resume is way above just Manny, youre laying too much emphasis on just Manny, its more than him its the entire body of work that adds up and ends with Manny. Floyd resume is so much more legit opposed to Mannys and thats what fans dont see nor understand, you got to know boxing to see through all the fan bs to see the real merit in a fight, its not just winning its how whom and when, and most important was the opponents form at the time.

Thurman was broken its obvious and every Manny fan trys to make him out to be a beast he was nearly stopped by Lopez a B+ guy after a 2 yr out with surgery, dont start the lion in his prime BS, he was a guy Roach said has fought injured for years , " When he stopped hurting guys " said Roach, remember those breadcrumbs I said are everywhere.