Manny Pacquiao vs. Roy Jones Jr, who ranks higher all-time?

[pasawayako]

After Elroy The Great was Banned, then Curtis Harper was banned, comes the next ALT of Elroy.

That guy is a pure hater. lol.

[Affogato`]

Manny Pacquiao better resume imo

Roy jones fell so hard after 49-1 he should have quit earlier

[aboutfkntime]

Jones had a higher ceiling, with higher caliber wins

Pac had longevity

prime, in their natural divisions... Jones was much harder to beat

he was near impossible to beat

whereas Pac lost to Morales and probably Marquez at least once

Jones was a killer

their careers had different bell-curves

the green line is Pac, the blue line is Roy...
























































and the red line is Mayweather

[Zaroku]

After Elroy The Great was Banned, then Curtis Harper was banned, comes the next ALT of Elroy.

We been on this site a long time! All the old guys keep getting banned. I think I’ve been banned 8 or 9 times.

Every time I get unbanned it’s the same dudes arguing about the same stuff.

[QueensburyRules]

Jones had a higher ceiling, with higher caliber wins

Pac had longevity

prime, in their natural divisions... Jones was much harder to beat

he was near impossible to beat

whereas Pac lost to Morales and probably Marquez at least once

Jones was a killer

their careers had different bell-curves

the green line is Pac, the blue line is Roy...

and the red line is Mayweather

- -U been tootin' the red line?

[Fat_asian]

This is like the argument of who vs Ali and Tyson is better. It comes down to what eras you were accustomed to. If you grew up with Roy then rjj was the man. If you saw a young Manny Pacquiao vs lehdwo lebala for the first time, you would.say pac.

[bojangles1987]

Pacquiao by a mile. Well, maybe not a mile but it's definitely not a question.

Roy at his best was as good as any fighter I've ever watched, but Manny's accomplishments put Roy to shame.

[aboutfkntime]

ceteris paribus... if all things are equal

so, if both guys were naturally the same weight... nobody moving up/down

nobody in their right mind would back Pacquiao to beat Jones

[hugh grant]

nobody in their right mind would back Pacquiao to beat Jones

You've got strange and imaginative ways of assessing things.
Many people had Pac favourite to beat floyd having started 3 divisions lower so why wouldn't people have Pac favourite to beatbrjj? Pac s the p4pking. If Pac started at middleweight h ed win titles up to super, super, super heavyweight

It's not about h2h anyways it's who's greater

[champion4ever]

Hands down it's Pacquiao. Manny had the more storied career. Not only that but he was also in some very memorable and entertaining bouts too; Most of which he won and some of them he lost. However, over all his resume was much better than Roy Jones.