Did Joe Calzaghe lose in his prime to Robin Reid

[Marchegiano]

Nah, Joe won that.

[Cobra Curry]

I had Joe edging this at the time. Robin was a good fighter, got absolutely stitched up in Germany vs Sven Ottke.

[Chollo Vista]

Very very close fight against a tough but limited fighter. Depending on how you scored the 7th round and with a few swing rounds, one can have it for Reid with the deduction.

[redmish]

It was close and Robon Reid landed plenty of right hands that night. Could have gone either way. All fighters have close fights like that though.