Did Joe Calzaghe lose in his prime to Robin Reid

[Chollo Vista]

Many people seem to think so. What are your thoughts and how do you remember scoring the fight?

[removed]

It was a close fight, could've gone either way from what I remember but I've not watched it for years, thanks for the link.

[sunny31]

Bad night for Calzaghe, I felt he just edged it out...115-112 maybe 114-113.

But it's one of those fights where the fighter who wasnt expected to do much, does a whole lot, and so there is always an overreaction.

Calzaghe blew hot and cold with his performances for sure.

[SheldonPurdy]

Yes he lost that fight clearly and he knows it himself

[removed]

Yes he lost that fight clearly and he knows it himself

Hi Robin.

[DreamFighter]

it was an either way decision, shame we didnt get the usual rematch that champions offer after an either way fight.
Reid went back to trying to win non-recognised titles, and Joe went back to fighting no hopers with Rick Thornberry next, so you can see the intent from their immediate resumes straight after.

[PRINCEKOOL]

Strange the way their was no rematch, as they where both British fighters 'With decent fan-bases'.

[SheldonPurdy]

There was no rematch becuz calzaghe didn’t want it. There’s a YouTube video called calzaghe getting his **** pushed in. Someone upload it ��

[Chollo Vista]

How did you guy's score round 7?

[VatoMulatto]

That was a damn close fight. Every undefeated fighter has at least one or two fights that could've gone either.