Was Castillo robbed of a victory over Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

[Kball15]

he wasnt robbed but i dont think he deserved the decision. u could make the argument that he did, but it just didnt seem right to award him the win. i had it a close fight

[Super_Lightweight]

Floyd did not dominate the rematch, but he won fairly from what I've seen. Oddly the scores were closer I believe.

[deliveryman]

Wow, another newbie joins the forum and makes the same ****ing topic. Here we go again:

How on earth was this fight a Robbery?

Why do you even bring up Lederman's scorecard? Or the HBO team?

You do realize that the majority of the ringside press scored that fight easily for Mayweather.

Anyway, the fight was close, I thought if the fight was 15 rounds Castillo definitely would of won it. However, he gave WAY too many of the early rounds away. Fights that could of been scored either way are not robberies.

Castillo fans always seem to forget about the first 5 rounds of the fight, as if those rounds don't matter.

And let's not forget Mayweather was fighting with one arm -- his left arm, which he couldn't jab or hook effectively. Watch the rematch, where Floyd had an effective jab.

[mic573]

Floyd did not dominate the rematch, but he won fairly from what I've seen. Oddly the scores were closer I believe.

He didn't dominate but he clearly won the fight without a doubt. I had that fight 116-112.

[realboxingfan]

Floyd did not dominate the rematch, but he won fairly from what I've seen. Oddly the scores were closer I believe.

IMO he clearly won the rematch.

[renren40]

Catillo should have knocked him out bottom line thats the only definite way to win in boxing now

[mic573]

Catillo should have knocked him out bottom line thats the only definite way to win in boxing now

He couldn't even though I'm sure he tried.

[Hitman18]

Just to clear things up, Im talking about Castillo-Mayweather 1. And for absolutely anyone saying that Castillo wasn't robbed, then you must be a pretty boy fan or mexican hater, or just like the idiot judges that scored the fight. Look at the poll, it is very clear that Castillo was ROBBED, and when I say ROBBED I mean ROBBED! If you still disagree, then you must be a fu**ing idiot!

[deliveryman]

Just to clear things up, Im talking about Castillo-Mayweather 1. And for absolutely anyone saying that Castillo wasn't robbed, then you must be a pretty boy fan or mexican hater, or just like the idiot judges that scored the fight. Look at the poll, it is very clear that Castillo was ROBBED, and when I say ROBBED I mean ROBBED! If you still disagree, then you must be a fu**ing idiot!

Right the poll with 15 votes... how accurate.

This thread has been done a billion times, and it's always 50-50 on who won the fight.

You're accusing the people who think Floyd won that fight as "nuthuggers" yet you say this with a big picture of Castillo in your avatar rofl. Hypocrite?

[mic573]

Just to clear things up, Im talking about Castillo-Mayweather 1. And for absolutely anyone saying that Castillo wasn't robbed, then you must be a pretty boy fan or mexican hater, or just like the idiot judges that scored the fight. Look at the poll, it is very clear that Castillo was ROBBED, and when I say ROBBED I mean ROBBED! If you still disagree, then you must be a fu**ing idiot!

Castillo is my favorite active fighter right now and he was not robbed. Did he deserve the win? I think so but he was not robbed.