Who deserves the Canelo payday?

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Rank these fighters in order of resume.

Billy Joe Saunders
Callum Smith
Jermall Charlo
Ryota Murata
Demetrius Andrade


Who has actually earned it by beating the best opposition?

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Best 3 wins.

Saunders:
Lee, Eubank Jr, Lemieux

Smith:
Groves, N’Dam, Fielding

Charlo:
Williams, Trout, Korobov

Murata:
N’Dam, Brant, Butler

Andrade:
Culcay, Martirosyan, Sulecki

[Luilun]

Callum Smith the rest are bum slayers

[4truth]

Callum Smith the rest are bum slayers

Callum Smith is drained at 168 even without a special Canelo clause. Please! No more fights with handicaps in the contract.

I like Andrade. He can't really be handicapped and the main reason his resume sucks is because nobody want to fight him.

[Fangedgrowl]

BJS and it isnt even close. Actually Golovkin does but he wasnt part of the poll. I know there are alot of people that hate him on here. But his resume is better than any of these guys.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

BJS and it isnt even close. Actually Golovkin does but he wasnt part of the poll. I know there are alot of people that hate him on here. But his resume is better than any of these guys.

I’m a big GGG fan bro. I didn’t include him because he’s fighting his Mandatory in late March/early April so is out of the running for May 2.

[ShaneMosleySr]

The correct answer is Gennady Golovkin since he’s the first unified world champion in the history of boxing to lose his titles by majority decision and not get a rematch. But with the choices I was given, I’ll go:

1. Callum Smith

2. Billy Joe Saunders

3. Demetrius Andrade

4. Ryota Murata

5. Jermall Charlo

Charlo would be higher but he turned down career high paydays to fight Andrade and Alvarez, so he really doesn’t deserve anything.

[Fangedgrowl]

I’m a big GGG fan bro. I didn’t include him because he’s fighting his Mandatory in late March/early April so is out of the running for May 2.

I didnt say you hated him, there are some petty people on here that do though, yet their hero wont fight anyone ranked. Ex Charlo,

[GhostofDempsey]

Saunders based upon your list. GGG if we are speaking truthfully.

[Mammoth]

Callum Smith the rest are bum slayers

Maybe if Smith didn't just get a massive gift