Official bad scorecard thread 2020.

[BaguMka]

I'd add Weisfeld's 117-111 Loma/Lopez card as well. Rounds 8-11 were as clear as you can have. Weisfeld had 9th going to Lopez. [almost] Full round below. Lopez lands one nice hook, literally everything else misses or gets blocked, while Loma lands a great 4 hit combo to the head that stumbles Lopez, as well as multiple jabs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dniQLbQ7HA

No you all wrong will tell you these clowns aka ee fighter haters or simply racists. 12-0 or 11-1 in Lopez favour. Being serious Fkucking disaster. It was a draw or Loma pulled if off. Even Bud and Dre had it a draw

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Yeah, it should be.

https://eyeonthering.com/boxing/mark-magsayo-vs-rigoberto-hermosillo

Those are only 4 fan scorecards, but most had it very close. It was a higher workrate (Hermosillo) Vs more power (Magsayo) kind of fight.
Hermosillo outworked him badly in a lot of rounds.

boxingscenes article on the fight says the following:
Judge Rudy Barragan turned in his second straight horrible ringside performance of the night, scoring the contest a suspension-worthy 100-90 in favor of Magsayo.

Thanks for the heads up, I’ll add it to the list.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

I'd add Weisfeld's 117-111 Loma/Lopez card as well. Rounds 8-11 were as clear as you can have. Weisfeld had 9th going to Lopez. [almost] Full round below. Lopez lands one nice hook, literally everything else misses or gets blocked, while Loma lands a great 4 hit combo to the head that stumbles Lopez, as well as multiple jabs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dniQLbQ7HA

I was genuinely debating adding that card tbh, I had it 115-113 Lopez and 117-111 felt a little too wide. I gave Loma rounds 8-11 on my card too. I can’t really see how you can give him less than 4.

A lot of people had it 116-112 Lopez though so he might have only scored one round the wrong way. So he just escapes the list this time.

[famicommander]

I don't think 117-111 was far off for Loma-Lopez. I had 116-112.

[famicommander]

The British Boxing Board of Control (BBBofC) has launched an investigation on English ringside boxing judge Terry O'Connor who is alleged to have looked away from the fight he was judging on Saturday.

Matchroom promoter Eddie Hearn questioned whether O'Connor was looking at his mobile phone while scoring Lewis Ritson's controversial win over Miguel Vazquez at the East of England Showground Arena on Saturday.

Hearn tweeted a picture of the incident and wrote: "If that's a phone (and I presume it is) then then BBBofC should immediately remove him."

https://www.espn.com/boxing/story/_/id/30148289/boxing-judge-investigated-looking-phone-fight

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

https://www.espn.com/boxing/story/_/...ng-phone-fight

Unfortunately mate I expect it just be swept under the rug.

Fat Terry will get a slap on the wrist and Robert Smith will continue looking after his mates.

The promoters are the only ones who can take action, Hearn, Warren, MTK should refuse to employ Terry O’Connor on their cards like Arum is claiming he will do to Julie Lederman.

[famicommander]

Some bad cards already this weekend:
Fernando Villarreal 119-109 for Soto over Buitrago
Yury Koptsev 118-110 for Kambosos Jr over Selby

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Some bad cards already this weekend:
Fernando Villarreal 119-109 for Soto over Buitrago
Yury Koptsev 118-110 for Kambosos Jr over Selby

Dunno where that 118-110 came from...

[_Rexy_]

When the year is finished, we should tally up which judges were the worst and send it off to the promoters

[Ochoa780]

I wish these judges had a sort of group like the refs in the nfl and nba where they get graded and watched and get promoted and demoted based on how they perform.

Too many bad judges that dont get reprimanded