Who did better against Floyd? Pacquiao or Maidana in the first fight?

[hugh grant]

But if both fights were fought in the losers own country we know Floyd would have 2 losses on record.

[Ca$ual Fan]

OP must’ve been jerking off while watching poll results and reading posts in this thread

[STREET CLEANER]

The Maidana fights were exciting. Maidana took chances and pushed forward.

The Pac fight was a typical Floyd fight. Good for the first three rounds and then a boring schooling.

[Curtis Harper]

The Maidana that fought May would have won/robbed at least 1 of the 2 fights vs Pac

[boxinggod101]

even Guerrero did better than Pacquiao. this thread should ask who did better Oscar, Maidana or Cotto instead.

You bugging lol. Guerrero didnt do sh#t...

[boxinggod101]

I remember Maidana being manhandled by past it overweight Morales. It was definitely time for Floyd to cashout

[ShoulderRoll]

The Maidana that fought May would have won/robbed at least 1 of the 2 fights vs Pac

I would have loved to see that Maidana vs Pacquiao.

[MEXICAN STYLE]

Maidana clearly

[Ganondorf]

This is not even something I have to think about or consider.

Floyd vs Maidana 1 was close. Floyd vs Manny Pacquiao was not close.

[Offline]

Manny fought clean. If Maidana fights clean he would’ve gotten washed. I can’t believe people give him credit for that trash.