Who did better against Floyd? Pacquiao or Maidana in the first fight?

[ShoulderRoll]

Be honest.

[Robi13]

Maidana had me thinking he won against Floyd, I didn’t get the same sentiment with Pacquiao... so i say Maidana did better

[Ivansmamma]

Maidana did far better. Fight should have been a draw, Floyd did not beat him in the first fight.

[Nash out]

Maidana took 4/5 rounds, Pac won 2.

[KING MEAT]

maidana gave floyd a better fight reason for the immediate rematch.

pac 100% got schooled. no need to see that again.

[jmart93]

Maidana for sure.... I think Cotto gave mayweather a better fight than Pac

[ShoulderRoll]

Maidana for sure.... I think Cotto gave mayweather a better fight than Pac

You might be right about Cotto.

[hugh grant]

Although many believe Floyd lost both fights, both Pac and maidana deserve credit for different reasons.
Floyd fought scared against pac the smaller fighter who Floyd said he'd ko. Whilst with maidana at times people who didn't know better or boxing might have thought ref should stop fight to save Floyd from further punishment.

[Madison Boxing]

Maidana. He got stuck into mayweather, i thought the 2nd fight was close too as did the judges if i remember

[Marchegiano]

Mosley, Maidana, De La Hoya, Cotto, Judah, Castillo(both times), and Canelo all did better than Pacquiao