Is Zab Judah a HoF fighter?

[Thraxox]

Is Zab Judah a HoF fighter? He was at one point the undisputed Welterweight, and has a relatively short prime. Because after his loss to Carlos Baldomir, it was all down hill for Judah.

But he has accomplishments, he defended his IBF lightwelterweight for 5 times before losing to Kosta Tzyu for the undisputed. And then won against Cory Spinks to become the undisputed Welterweight.

[elfag]

He will probably get in eventually, his resume is deep even if he didnt always win.

It just depends on who else is up against him those years in the nominations. Some years you get 3 guys who are basically a lock for it,

This year the nominees are "Jorge Arce, Timothy Bradley, Vuyani Bungu, Joel Casamayor, Diego Corrales, Carl Froch, Bernard Hopkins, Sergio Martinez, Juan Manuel Marquez, Shane Mosley, Antonio Tarver and Israel Vazquez."

Thats a lot of good fighters not going to make it because to me Hopkins, JMM and Mosley are basically shoe ins.

[DumpkinsPlus5]

He will probably get in eventually, his resume is deep even if he didnt always win.

It just depends on who else is up against him those years in the nominations. Some years you get 3 guys who are basically a lock for it,

This year the nominees are "Jorge Arce, Timothy Bradley, Vuyani Bungu, Joel Casamayor, Diego Corrales, Carl Froch, Bernard Hopkins, Sergio Martinez, Juan Manuel Marquez, Shane Mosley, Antonio Tarver and Israel Vazquez."

Thats a lot of good fighters not going to make it because to me Hopkins, JMM and Mosley are basically shoe ins.

Yes, Zab should get in...

[PRINCEKOOL]

Of course YES.

[Ca$ual Fan]

Meh

Getting embarrassed by Baldomir and Clottey in your prime doesn't make up for it

[Rip Chudd]

Yeah, he'll get in

[bluebeam]

He will probably get in eventually, his resume is deep even if he didnt always win.

It just depends on who else is up against him those years in the nominations. Some years you get 3 guys who are basically a lock for it,

This year the nominees are "Jorge Arce, Timothy Bradley, Vuyani Bungu, Joel Casamayor, Diego Corrales, Carl Froch, Bernard Hopkins, Sergio Martinez, Juan Manuel Marquez, Shane Mosley, Antonio Tarver and Israel Vazquez."

Thats a lot of good fighters not going to make it because to me Hopkins, JMM and Mosley are basically shoe ins.

The class has already been announced bro. Marquez, Hopkins, Mosley all got in. The others you named didnt

[KillaMane26]

It would be a crime not to....Its Zab Judah!!

He might not have won his biggest fights but he fought everyone and got some good late wins in his career.

[bluebeam]

Zab should get in the hall of fame. It's fighters in the hall that zab had a better career than.

He was the man at 140 for a period of time.

He held all the straps at 147.

Then his career took a nose dive. Then just when we thought he was finished he went back to 140 and won another title.

[GhostofDempsey]

He likely gets in, whether he deserves it is subjective. His best wins were Cory Spinks and Matthysse.