IB Times says Oscar and Manny won

[TheMyspaceDayz]

If someone says Castillo beat Mayweather then I’d agree and add “117-111. It was not even close.” To say that Oscar or Manny won though is ridiculous. Get real.

[D4thincarnation]

he won 3 rounds on two cards, and two on the other.

Deservedly so. He was good but a lot of wasted work.

Judges got it wrong.

He won 4 rounds.

Started slow and tired in the championship rounds.

Cotto walked out in disgust at the cards.

He made Floyd miss and made him pay several times in the mid rounds.

And this was a past prime Cotto, not as sharp, quick, not the combinations and not the stamina he had 4/5 years earlier.

[LacedUp]

Judges got it wrong.

He won 4 rounds.

Started slow and tired in the championship rounds.

Cotto walked out in disgust at the cards.

He made Floyd miss and made him pay several times in the mid rounds.

And this was a past prime Cotto, not as sharp, quick, not the combinations and not the stamina he had 4/5 years earlier.

I don't think so.

it doesn't matter what a prime Cotto would do, he didn't fight a prime Floyd either tbh.

[D4thincarnation]

I don't think so.

it doesn't matter what a prime Cotto would do, he didn't fight a prime Floyd either tbh.

Taking (vacations) is not the same as getting your head smashed in by Margarito and then Pacquiao.

Those types of beatings take it out of you.

Floyd came back with more muscle and size

[BoomBapTrap]

PAC vs. Floyd was closer than what Floyd fans try to make it seem.
I had 7-5 Floyd, but can definitely even see a draw as there just wasn’t much action from either side.
It was a terrible performance from both guys.

I had Floyd beating Oscar. He dodged a lot of Oscar’s punches. But Oscar did put up a good fight. Seeing Oscar performance against Floyd, imagining if it were prime PAC vs. Floyd would’ve been fireworks.

Floyd smart tho. He ducked that one.

[Robbie Barrett]

PAC vs. Floyd was closer than what Floyd fans try to make it seem.
I had 7-5 Floyd, but can definitely even see a draw as there just wasn’t much action from either side.
It was a terrible performance from both guys.

I had Floyd beating Oscar. He dodged a lot of Oscar’s punches. But Oscar did put up a good fight. Seeing Oscar performance against Floyd, imagining if it were prime PAC vs. Floyd would’ve been fireworks.

Floyd smart tho. He ducked that one.

Wasn't close at all. Mayweather clearly won.

1.Mayweather made a 50/50 offer.
2.Pacquiao turned it down saying he didn't want to do testing the week of the fight.
3.Mayweather offered a 14 day cut off for testing. Fulfilling Pacquiao's request of "not the week of the fight"
4. Pacquiao turned that down.

Pacquiao ducked Mayweather.

[Roadblock]

If you follow the criteria for scoring rounds of pro boxing, then Pacquiao beat Floyd easily.

Only clean hard punches can be scored.
Floyd hardly landed any during the whole fight.

Effective Aggression

Which was Pacquiao.

And Ring generalship, running to the ropes is not being the ring general.

Defense, all Floyd did was grab hold and run, not boxing defensive moves.


Touch jabs mean nothing in the pro game.

lol if only you knew anything about boxing, now youre writing your own rules based on what you think is official scoring criteria.

Looking at the scorecard I think you have no clue.

[D4thincarnation]

lol if only you knew anything about boxing, now youre writing your own rules based on what you think is official scoring criteria.

Looking at the scorecard I think you have no clue.

Nope, they are the official guidelines you noob.

You just showed yourself up

[Larry the boss]

PAC vs. Floyd was closer than what Floyd fans try to make it seem.
I had 7-5 Floyd, but can definitely even see a draw as there just wasn’t much action from either side.
It was a terrible performance from both guys.

I had Floyd beating Oscar. He dodged a lot of Oscar’s punches. But Oscar did put up a good fight. Seeing Oscar performance against Floyd, imagining if it were prime PAC vs. Floyd would’ve been fireworks.

Floyd smart tho. He ducked that one.

how did floyd duck Prime Oscar??? please explain

[Robbie Barrett]

Nope, they are the official guidelines you noob.

You just showed yourself up

It doesn't say in any guidelines only hard punches count.