Andre Ward has Manny Pacquiao as FOY!!!

[Weebler I]

Ward salty that Canelo stepped up two divisions and knocked out Kovalev? Add to that a very good win over Danny Jacobs.

Thurman is a very good win, Broner is not. Thus Canelo has obviously had a better year.

[abracada]

... while Bradley has Canelo...

(moments ago on ESPN+...)

Pacman outgunned Thurman, pacman is well well well past his prime. He deserves it.

[a.rihn]

I figured they will split the difference. Name Canelo Fighter of the Year, but name Pac-Thurman Fight of the Year.

Pacman entered 2019 already basically a legend - his fights bolstered that. Canelo is still building his legacy, drawing people in (and signing huge contracts), and 2019 has been be integral in all of that for him.

[Mr. Philadel]

Pac is a good choice!! Nelo is the P4P King but not FOY imo

[4truth]

You could make a good case for either though I would disqualify Canelo right out of the gate. If you cannot face opponents without imposing handicaps on them, your accomplishments are tainted.

[SinderellaMan]

Both reasonable picks.
Canelo is growing into something special & Pac has always been a gift from the boxing gods

[MDPopescu]

Ward salty that Canelo stepped up two divisions and knocked out Kovalev? Add to that a very good win over Danny Jacobs.

Thurman is a very good win, Broner is not. Thus Canelo has obviously had a better year.

... In fact it was Ward who said (live, just after the Yarde fight) that Kovalev should definitely take the "Canelo money fight" and then retire...

[MDPopescu]

Pac is a good choice!! Nelo is the P4P King but not FOY imo

Let's not forget that at the end of 2019 there will be a FOY, and also the Fighter of the Decade !!!

[ReggieKray]

Ward needs to come out of retirement to get his a** whooped...

[MaksBox]

Sorry, but Kovalev sold his belt... cannot give Canelo much credit there.

Pacman, at 40 years old beating up on juniors... THAT is FOTY. (all while being a freaking SENATOR!)