Is it wrong for me to rank Lennox Lewis as the greatest HW of all time?

[Marchegiano]

He retired undefeated. That's good enough to make the top 10.

No, I mean why isn't he considered too old to compare?

[Unknown Champ]

Lennox The Lion Lewis is the GOAT HW

[HitmanTommy]

No, I mean why isn't he considered too old to compare?

Because while very old, he isn't exactly stone age era like Jack Johnson.

[MisterPullman]

Vitali beats foreman btw

Vitali, Ali, and Lewis are probably ATG heavyweights

Lewis and Vitali are pretty close, either one can beat each other depending on the night.

1. Lewis
2. Vitali
3. Ali
4. Foreman
5. Holyfield
6. Marciano
7. Wlad
8. Holmes
9. Frazier
10. Tunney

[NORMNEALON]

1.ali
2.louis
3.holmes
4.johnson
5.lewis
6.holyfield
7.foreman
8.dempsey
9.marciano
10. Frazier


....that's off the top of my head....I think most people will have lewis in their top 10, even top 5. He is an all time great for sure ...but I think legacy plays a big part and I dont think he can top ali for that one . Nor joe Louis....after those two within reason I feel the rest are interchangeable depending on how u look at it .

[Willy Wanker]

Very respectable opinion.

[redmish]

Not at all. He was excellent and it's your own opinion.

[sicko]

My Favorite Heavyweight of all time but #1 is always debatable

That man came to the US, took on everybody and WON and when he did lose he redeemed all those loses in dominating Fashion
[IMG]https://media1.*****.com/media/8eIlS6TpS8l7W/*****.gif[/IMG]