My All-Time P4P

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Legends456
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2019
    • 1353
    • 160
    • 949
    • 52,257

    #1

    My All-Time P4P

    1. Sugar Ray Robinson
    Why: his dominance across decades is unparalleled. Simply the greatest boxer to ever lace up gloves.

    2. Melankomas
    Why: this Ancient Greek boxer was the ultimate defensive fighter. The legends say he never once was hit at all. Or perhaps he was never hit cleanly; either way he never lost and didn’t take any damage.

    3. Ray Leonard
    Why: perhaps the singularly most talented fighter overall in history. He was able to fight defensively, stick-and-move, and go toe to toe with one of the most feared punchers in history and keep his feet. If only he had had more fights.

    4. Muhammad Ali
    Why: he had the mobility and skill of a welterweight but ruled the heavyweight division in an era of elite comp. We will never know just how amazing this athlete was, as he missed his prime years in the ring.

    5. Bernard Hopkins
    The Alien was legendary in his ability to fight at the top level for decades. He never shied away from big fights, and proved himself time and time again.

    6. Marvin Hagler
    Why: a legendary fighter and a man among men. Chin of steel and fists of dynamite made this fighter a force to be reckoned with.

    7. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
    Why: simply the best of his generation, no one was able to beat him. His defense, chin, and accuracy made him a legend in our time. If his biggest fights had been against prime opponents, he would be even higher on my list.

    8. Harry Greb
    Why: Legendary one-eyed volume puncher who went toe to toe with the best of his era and fought well over 200 times. He also was willing to matchup with black boxers in an era where discrimination and segregation was still commonplace.

    9. Joe Frazier
    Why: an elite and true Swarmer whose style captivated me when I first saw it on grainy faded video footage as a young teen. Only boxer to defeat the legendary Ali in what could be argued was still his prime years.

    10. Roberto Duran
    Why: great pressure fighter who went toe to toe with the best of his golden generation across several weight classes. Probably the most merciless and devastating puncher pound for pound in boxing history. Would have been even greater if he had more discipline in and out of the ring.
  • UNBANNED
    Undisputed Champion
    • Oct 2019
    • 1432
    • 62
    • 21
    • 33,301

    #2
    Not a good list tbh

    Duran way too low and Frazier is not Top 10 ATG. Then where's Foreman?

    JCC Sr? RJJ? Armstrong? Joe Louis? Jack Johnson? Pernell? Benitez?

    Comment

    • The D3vil
      WBA/WBC/WBO/IBF/Lineal
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Mar 2016
      • 6353
      • 1,624
      • 1,430
      • 56,286

      #3
      Ali was nowhere near in his prime when he lost to Frazier in '71.

      His prime was '64-67.

      And Frazier ahead of Joe Louis, George Foreman (who demolished him twice), Lennox Lewis, Jack Dempsey, Larry Holmes? I wouldn't put Frazier ahead of Rocky Marciano, FFS.

      And that Greek dude, really?

      They didn't have Queensbury rules back then.

      You don't even know what rules they fought by.

      Bernard Hopkins?

      He's not even greater than Roy Jones, Jr., who he lost to.

      This is a half-assed list.

      Go back to the lab, junior

      Comment

      • MehdiQaos
        Contender
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • May 2018
        • 244
        • 8
        • 5
        • 11,566

        #4
        Hopkins, Frazier and the greek boxer don't belong to the top 10

        Comment

        • Murcielago
          Interim Champion
          Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
          • Dec 2003
          • 712
          • 103
          • 14
          • 34,225

          #5
          Originally posted by Legends456

          2. Melankomas
          Why: this Ancient Greek boxer was the ultimate defensive fighter. The legends say he never once was hit at all. Or perhaps he was never hit cleanly; either way he never lost and didn’t take any damage.
          .
          Dio says he never lost a match, hit an opponent, or was struck by an opponent.

          Comment

          Working...
          TOP