Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Pound for Pound Update: November 2019

[Legends456]

Josh Taylor cracks the top ten.

I think I'm going to be SICK! P4P?! HOW?! Did you guys see Viktor Postol, Ivan Baranchyk and Regis Prograis whooping the 'Tart-Tomato'? No way this bum has the skills to jump weight divisions and be champion at 147! That's what P4P do!

Josh Taylor is OVERRATED!!!

I think this list has him in the top ten due to his beating three undefeated in a row... however I get the impression you disagree with the decisions in those, I’d have to go back and watch the others but thought he won a close decision with Prograis.

[Legends456]

This is worse than I thought, I just seen Bumchenko ahead of Terence Crawford. Would Luke Campbell ever done this to Terence Crawford?! WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON?!

I’m a big supporter of Lomachenko but I agree with you he should not be ranked ahead of Crawford. Lomachenko has not looked that dominant since going up to lightweight; 135 is his limit, and 130 is better.
Even Vasya himself when asked said that Crawford is his #1 p4p. Crawford is my favorite welterweight but he really needs to get some big fights, and soon... I am not surprised he’s slipping on people’s lists because he’s just been too quiet lately and hasn’t beat anyone of note, unless you count a washed Khan. I still think he’s one of the most talented boxers in the last 30 or so years, but he has to get the fights.

[1hourRun]

I think this list has him in the top ten due to his beating three undefeated in a row... however I get the impression you disagree with the decisions in those, I’d have to go back and watch the others but thought he won a close decision with Prograis.

I’m a big supporter of Lomachenko but I agree with you he should not be ranked ahead of Crawford. Lomachenko has not looked that dominant since going up to lightweight; 135 is his limit, and 130 is better.
Even Vasya himself when asked said that Crawford is his #1 p4p. Crawford is my favorite welterweight but he really needs to get some big fights, and soon... I am not surprised he’s slipping on people’s lists because he’s just been too quiet lately and hasn’t beat anyone of note, unless you count a washed Khan. I still think he’s one of the most talented boxers in the last 30 or so years, but he has to get the fights.

You seem smart, I like you. Welcome.

[j.razor]

1. Nelo
2. Bud
3. Keith
4. Errol
5. D.Wilder
6. Devin
7. l0m0
8. Fury
9. Plant
10. Bivol

[Boxing Goat]

Hopefully, this finally puts the final nails in the coffin of this know-nothing idiots career. Is it not 100% obvious this guy DKSAB and can't leave personal feelings out of anything? It's pathetic.

[Santa_]

A WBA Super 130 belt that was supposed to be for ANDREW CANCIO. Cancio should be in line for that belt (well you know how the history of Machado's original belt was taken away by Gervonta).

King Santa was the 126 WBA Super Champ so he automatically gets a shot at that same title at 130. Nothing new here. I'm a fan of Cancio though, I'd like to see him get a Terremoto pay day in the future. That'd be a good fight.

[JOITATS]

good list

agree crawford should go down, based on his lack of challenge, and his best win being amir khan

[UNBANNED]

P4P is subjective... and highly over-rated imo...

Inoue leapfrogged Lomachenko, Crawford, and Canelo... after being exposed a little, by an old Donaire who dropped TWO divisions in the last year-or-so? ...

I have him a solid #4

Usyk, I love the guy... excellent fighter, and excellent guy... but he is one fight away from possibly being removed from the list entirely

Usyk beat 2x unproven guys, and thats it... I still remember what happened in the Bellew fight, Usyk did not look like a P4P fighter at all

not sure whats up there... I wish him all the best, but not sure how successful he will be at heavyweight

and Golovkin still on the list, after losing to Canelo and probably losing to Derevyanchenko... ?

I think there will be some " adjustments " over the next 12 months

I have the top 4...
Crawford/Lomachenko... #1 and #2, no particular order
Canelo
Inoue

I still have Canelo/Inoue one top win away from earning the top spot

Crawford needs to do something

because of his inactivity against anyone worth a damn, in 12 months I can see...
1) Canelo
2) Lomachenko
3) Inoue
4) Crawford

Good list, all good points

[Legends456]

1. Nelo
2. Bud
3. Keith
4. Errol
5. D.Wilder
6. Devin
7. l0m0
8. Fury
9. Plant
10. Bivol

It’s a decent list, but I’d put Bud at number one. I also wouldn’t have Fury in the top ten after how he looked against Wallin. I’d put Beterbiev at #8 instead. Also a bit confused by Thurman at #3... maybe you can explain your reasoning for that? Even if you feel he deserved a decision against PAC, he just doesn’t look that good to me anymore.

[The D3vil]

Yeah, you guys are right.

It's getting harder & harder for me to justify having Crawford at #1 with his lack of challenges, but it's just that I feel weird putting guys with under 20 fights as P4P #1s with Inoue & Lomachenko, & Usyk.

And I don't think Canelo beat GGG in either fight or Erislandy Lara, so I give him credit for his greatness, but he should have 4 losses in my book.

So, Crawford's just kind of #1 by default

It's too early to have Josh Taylor in the top 10 too.

Let's let him defend the belt a few times first.

I know I got Beterbiev on there, but he keeps knocking people the F out like Inoue, so it's kind hard to deny that.