Zab Judah Vs. Antonio Margarito: Who wins?

[psychopath]

he lookde shaky agaisnt lujan

Yes we cannot deny that Lujan sneak in some pretty good solid shots but it never rocked Margarito and put him on trouble. In fact Margarito walked through it and hurt the other guy very badly.

Now do you honestly think Zab can survive that kind of punishment? He wasn't hit solidly by PBF and yet Zab faded after the 5th round so that should tell us something about Zab.

[BigSlick]

Zab is not mentaly tough enough to fight Margarito.

[deuce_drop]

magrarito wins, margarito can take zab's punch, zab can't take marg's punch, period.

zab will fade after the fourth round and the rest of the fight would be margarito walking him down, applying pressure and roughing him up on the inside.

zab will lose by TKO to margarito......

[Briman15]

Why doesn't margarito make an offer to Judah already. It would be a good way of legitimizing all this hype.

[eazy_mas]

magrarito wins, margarito can take zab's punch, zab can't take marg's punch, period.

zab will fade after the fourth round and the rest of the fight would be margarito walking him down, applying pressure and roughing him up on the inside.

zab will lose by TKO to margarito......

If Margarito could punch Judah.

I not bais on this but Zab could win Margarito.

Effective punching and timeing is is the name of the game that Zab will play to win Margarito. But it could go in either side.

In Cintron fight Margarito seemed a bit stunted in one of the round but the difference in power goes for cintron. Judah could punch in a lot of punchs

[El Jesus]

I sincerely believe if Zab doesnt get hit, he wins. Hes too fast, too deceptive and fights out of the left hand stance. Nothing Margarito has shown me, other than in power, says he is good enough to take on all that. Zab would show up for this fight. Then probably get caught as hes winning on all scorecards...lol.

[Njord777]

The question comes down to this : Can Zab Judah remained focused enough for 12 rounds to use his superior skills and box?

One brain fart like he had against Baldomir, for example, and I think we see him on his back. Who hits harder, Carlos or Margarito? If you think Antonio does, well remember the chicken dance and running Zab had to do when he let Baldomir catch him late in their fight.

Judah has the skills to beat Margarito, and a big enough punch to earn some respect, but to be honest I doubt his ability to remain focused enough to clinch a win. If he can't get Margarito out of the fight he has to be on his game all night or possibly suffer for it worse than usual. If there is anything I give Margarito credit for, it's his size and probable strength that accompanies it.

[Easy-E]

magrarito wins, margarito can take zab's punch, zab can't take marg's punch, period.

zab will fade after the fourth round and the rest of the fight would be margarito walking him down, applying pressure and roughing him up on the inside.

zab will lose by TKO to margarito......

Says who???
Tony has never really been hit flush by a puncher like Zab.

[luistwentyone]

Says who???
Tony has never really been hit flush by a puncher like Zab.

noodle legs Zab ?

Antonio within 2 rds by KO