Let's face it, Miguel Cotto was average.

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Nash out
    BoxingScene Hall of Fame
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Nov 2018
    • 6124
    • 2,238
    • 1,851
    • 19,416

    #1

    Let's face it, Miguel Cotto was average.

    He won his first 15 fights against journeyman and somehow that was enough to get him a shot at the title, not against a great Champion, but against a very weak fighter for the open WBC Championship, Rocky Martinez, entering the fight with 8 losses, Cotto knocked him out (what a surprise!) *I hope you detect the sarcasm here*

    He then defended his belt against Demetrio Ceballos. Who this guy is, I have no idea, he entered the fight with a few wins and 4 losses, he gets another padded KO for his every growing bum City record. Next up Carlos Maussa, and that this guy was fighting for a world title is absolutely astonishing. He entered the fight 17-0, reason being, 11 of those 17 wins were against guys who had never won a fight in their careers! Cotto knocked him out. After Moussa hideous 17-0 start to his career, his last eight fight record was W3 L5, which was far more reflective of his ability.

    Defence number 4, Victoriano Sosa, again another relatively poor opponent, but by far Cotto's best win to date winning by KO. Sosa is best known for being victim number 30 of TBE. He then beat another average boxer in Lovemore Ndou, this time on points. Ndou lost 13 times before realising he was useless and hanging them up.

    Then Kelson Pinto. I have not heard of one name (Cotto aside) on this guys record. Cotto won by KO. Next up was big punching journeyman Randall Bailey, not a great fighter, but a worthy opponent as he was a big puncher at least. Randall Bailey is best known for losing 9 times. Then came DeMarcus Corley, an okay fighter who at least was willing to step in with anyone, Only problem was, ever time he did he lost (33 losses) including being victim #33 of TBE, and 51 wins.

    Then he beat Muhammadqodir Abdullaev (Yeah, I have no idea either) Cotto beat Ricardo Torres, a very basic fighter, best known for going 1-1 with Kendall Holt, which is by far the highlight of his career. To this day, Kendall says that he's so embarrassed by this loss, he can't sleep at night.

    Following this, Cotto knocked out the rubbish Gianluca Branco, a man who lost to Matthew Hatton (Matthew Hatton!) How could anybody lose to that plodder? Then came the biggest fight of Cotto's career so far, the feather-fisted, magic-man, Paulie Mallignaggi, they put on an entertaining fight with Cotto edging it by a knockdown, 114-113 Cotto. It's a well known fact, that late that night after the fight, in a fit of rage, Paulie Malignaggi actually did bust a g****.

    Cotto then knocked out Carlos Quintana, a man who didn't have a very good resume on the whole, but actually went 1-1 with Paul Williams, though was splattered all over the canvas by Andre Berto, so there's that to consider. Also lost to Keith "One Time" Thurman. A victory over Oktay Urkal followed, nothing else needs to be said on that one.

    Cotto then got a career best win in a good fight with Zab Judah, best known as victim #36 of TBE. A close and much debating decision win over Shane Mosley followed, Mosley known for being a great fighter and victim #41 of TBE. I scored it 117-111 Mosley, but Cotto's 0 was protected with this robbery.

    Then Alfonso Gomez came, a man best known for losing to Peter Manfredo. Cotto KO. He loves stopping these bums does Cotto. Then came the memorable fight with Antonio Margarito 36/5 at the time. Cotto faced defeat for the first time as the heavy handed Margarito scored a stoppage victory. Cotto bounced back by beating Michael Jennings, who I assume was some guy they just picked out from the crowd to take a beating.

    Cotto stepped back up a level to face Joshua Clottey and "won" a split decision in a fight everybody knows he lost. Following this, Cotto took a beating from Manny Pacquiao, resulting in his second official loss. Cotto bounced back beating some guy called Yuri Foreman.

    Cotto then knocked out Ricardo Mayorga, a decent fighter, but ultimately an overrated slugger with 12 losses to his name. Cotto then got his revenge on Antonio Margarito (albeit with Margarito now being past his prime) Cotto's finest hour came, as he became victim #43 of TBE, actually winning 2 rounds in the process -118-110 TBE. Unfortunately for Cotto, his finest performance to date was followed by a very poor one as he lost 118-110 to Austin Trout in what was Trout's finest hour.

    Cotto then beat Delvin Rodriguez, a journeyman, and the shell of Sergio Martinez in a farcical bout. After Gennady Golovkin knocked all the fight out of Daniel Geale, Cotto picked up his left overs and scored another win. A big clash with Canelo Alvarez came (ATG and victim number 45 of TBE.) Canelo won a one-sided fight 118-110. Cotto then beat Yoshihiro Kamegai (?) and finished off his career losing to Sadam Ali of all people.

    Career rating 6/10.
    Last edited by Nash out; 08-06-2019, 06:37 PM.
  • Armchairhero
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Apr 2018
    • 1057
    • 41
    • 64
    • 26,850

    #2
    A bit harsh, I’d rate him as a solid champ. Not on the same level as the true super stars, but not far off. Was in some great fights and had a pleasing style to watch

    Comment

    • DuckAdonis
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Jul 2017
      • 7775
      • 197
      • 84
      • 188,446

      #3
      He did great Vs Floyd

      And he did not lose 10 rounds to Canelo

      Comment

      • boliodogs
        Undisputed Champion
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2008
        • 33358
        • 824
        • 1,782
        • 309,589

        #4
        I agree that Cotto is overrated by many. He was an inconsistent fighter being better in some fights than others. He could be a dirty fighter hitting low on purpose and picking guys up and throwing them down. He was a poor champion at 154 and 160 defending against lousy challengers. He was the pretend middleweight champ. He never once fought at 160. He won the middleweight title at a 159 pound catchweight and defended it against Geale at a 157 pound catchweight instead of fighting GGG who had already KOed Geale. I don't believe Margarito had loaded gloves or he would have KOed Cotto in the 1st round instead of coming from way behind to win. Cotto is very popular and I think his popularity made him seem better than he really was. He wasn't bad but he was not that good either in my opinion. I agree that Clottey deserved the win over Cotto.

        Comment

        • Nash out
          BoxingScene Hall of Fame
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Nov 2018
          • 6124
          • 2,238
          • 1,851
          • 19,416

          #5
          Originally posted by boliodogs
          I agree that Cotto is overrated by many. He was an inconsistent fighter being better in some fights than others. He could be a dirty fighter hitting low on purpose and picking guys up and throwing them down. He was a poor champion at 154 and 160 defending against lousy challengers. He was the pretend middleweight champ. He never once fought at 160. He won the middleweight title at a 159 pound catchweight and defended it against Geale at a 157 pound catchweight instead of fighting GGG who had already KOed Geale. I don't believe Margarito had loaded gloves or he would have KOed Cotto in the 1st round instead of coming from way behind to win. Cotto is very popular and I think his popularity made him seem better than he really was. He wasn't bad but he was not that good either in my opinion. I agree that Clottey deserved the win over Cotto.
          Great post. Yeah, I agree with all of this.

          Comment

          • BigStomps
            Banned
            • Sep 2016
            • 7829
            • 259
            • 1
            • 82,514

            #6
            Funny how some lame's who've never laced up a pair of gloves, let alone been in a real fight cause they always run like Cowards when it comes to fight, have the audacity to criticize what another man has accomplished in the ring,.....
            The nerve of some of these coward's,.... 😆🤣

            Comment

            • Westsideloc6
              Amateur
              • Mar 2017
              • 21
              • 5
              • 0
              • 8,442

              #7
              Everybody you just named on his resume. He beat and damaged those guys at their absolute best and many were undefeated and in their prime. All their losses piled up after getting beat down by Cotto

              Comment

              • ralex
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jul 2017
                • 4988
                • 1,647
                • 2,753
                • 68,070

                #8
                Lol. I’m not a Cotto fan but he was far from average

                Comment

                • Nash out
                  BoxingScene Hall of Fame
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Nov 2018
                  • 6124
                  • 2,238
                  • 1,851
                  • 19,416

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Westsideloc6
                  Everybody you just named on his resume. He beat and damaged those guys at their absolute best and many were undefeated and in their prime. All their losses piled up after getting beat down by Cotto
                  Sure! Yeah, this guy was never the same again. Carlos Maussa, and that this guy was fighting for a world title is absolutely astonishing. He entered the fight 17-0, reason being, 11 of those 17 wins were against guys who had never won a fight in their careers! Cotto knocked him out. After Moussa hideous 17-0 start to his career, his last eight fight record was W3 L5, which was far more reflective of his ability.

                  Comment

                  • Nash out
                    BoxingScene Hall of Fame
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Nov 2018
                    • 6124
                    • 2,238
                    • 1,851
                    • 19,416

                    #10
                    Originally posted by ralex
                    Lol. I’m not a Cotto fan but he was far from average
                    He wasn't average, but it's to emphasize the point of how overrated he is by quite a lot of people. And my many points here state this imo.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP