Comments Thread For: Latest 147 Conquest Adds New Layer To Pac-Mayweather Debate

[Cicada]

Floyd is the better fighter

But Pac is greater.

accurate assessment.

[BigTroll]

Floyd Joy Mayweather 😂

Get to the chase:

Castillo BEAT Joy JR by 2-3 rounds but naturally was ROBBED of the win😂

ODH was old out of Prime but still beat Joy Jr and Naturally was ROBBED of the win.

Joy went on extended Vacations when challenged by Margarito nearly messing his panties upon approach!!! He went the other way plus he got mad when challenged to fight the UNDEFEATED COTTO!!!

The whole problem with Floyd Joy Mayweather JR is WHEN he fought who he fought:

The champs were OLD, had problems, little, wee little etc...

Joy Jr never had the balls to fight another PRIME UNDEFEATED ELITE!!

Somebody should confute what I just said !!!!

Let’s make this easy😂😂👏👏👏👏

Somebody Name the UNDEFEATED PRIME ELITE WELTERWEIGHT with NO hindrances that Joy Jr fought in the last 15 years !!😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏

Canelo.. and it was over the 147 limit Floyd was 37 c anelo 23. Usually when a naturally bigger talented young 23 yr old phenom fights an aging great nearing 40, who wasn't even a big puncher at 47, the older guy gets a lot of credit.. but I guess not floyd

[BigTroll]

Well spoken!!

Yeah Castillo got Floyd out of his element in the first fight but Floyd was a younger boxer still improving and had a torn shoulder just like Pac man. Castillo and maidana were Floyd's toughest fights and he beat both in immediate rematches.. if he was afraid of challenges would he give those guys immediate rematches?

[tostao]

Must fight in seniours

[b Murphington]

The resumes and in ring accomplishments are pretty even if you ask me. They’ve both done a lot and you can make points for either or being better. Pacquiao’s might get the nod for starting off at a lighter weight.

I think Pacquiao was the bigger star if that means anything at all. He was and is more popular.

But I think Floyd was the better overall boxer for sure. I don’t see how you can argue with that.

The Floyd - Pacquiao fight was awful though. Biggest farce in the history of the sport.

[cameltoe]

Floyd Joy Mayweather 😂

Get to the chase:

Castillo BEAT Joy JR by 2-3 rounds but naturally was ROBBED of the win😂

ODH was old out of Prime but still beat Joy Jr and Naturally was ROBBED of the win.

Joy went on extended Vacations when challenged by Margarito nearly messing his panties upon approach!!! He went the other way plus he got mad when challenged to fight the UNDEFEATED COTTO!!!

The whole problem with Floyd Joy Mayweather JR is WHEN he fought who he fought:

The champs were OLD, had problems, little, wee little etc...

Joy Jr never had the balls to fight another PRIME UNDEFEATED ELITE!!

Somebody should confute what I just said !!!!

Let’s make this easy😂😂👏👏👏👏

Somebody Name the UNDEFEATED PRIME ELITE WELTERWEIGHT with NO hindrances that Joy Jr fought in the last 15 years !!😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏

Floyd’s Oscar> Manny’s Oscar.

And it’s the same story for all their common opponents.

So are you saying Pacquiao always chose strong fighters with no weaknesses, coming off wins?

Cos it’s amazing when you stack their resumes side by side, how Mayweather always fought fighters when they were in-form. Yet Pacquiao always chose them damaged and coming off loses.

But hey-ho. Keep throwing in the CAPS LOCK and it’ll help get your point across.

Maybe you can direct me to the Mayweather- Pacquiao conspiracy theory video where you prove Mayweather cheated by standing on his foot? 😂

[HarvardBlue]

Pacquiao is and will always be a legend in the sport of boxing.

Mayweather is not only a better fighter but he will always be remembered as the one that the legendary Pacquiao couldn't beat.

[Oregonian]

Insecure fanboy writer who can't see that lame fight for what it is.. A lame fight to cure insomnia lmao


Pac is way ahead of Floyd. Sports is about challenges. Pac has done it all.

———
Sure. Broner had lost 4 times when PAC fought him
Mathysse has lost and had not fought in 2 years
Mosley had lost to Floyd
Hatton had lost to Floyd
Oscar had lost to Floyd
Margarito had lost to Mosley
Cotto had lost to Margarito
Clottey had lost to Cotto
Rios has lost to Alvarado
Horn was a nobody and still beat PAC
Algieri was a nobody
PAC got KO’d by Marquez and has 7 losses

What challenges are you talking about?

[aboutfkntime]

Canelo.. and it was over the 147 limit Floyd was 37 c anelo 23. Usually when a naturally bigger talented young 23 yr old phenom fights an aging great nearing 40, who wasn't even a big puncher at 47, the older guy gets a lot of credit.. but I guess not floyd

Floyd beating Canelo the way he did at 38yo is MUCH better than Pac beating Keith

not even close

Thurman's beat win is scraping past Porter, and he does not appear to be the same fighter..... Porter would likely beat him now imo

this is just the usual sillyness before/after a Pac fight lol

[john l]

Pacquaio had his chance to prove he was better, he came up short. Pac and his fans had nothing but excuses after that fight.

Agree and Pac could have had the fight in 2010 but was "afraid of needles" even Roach said 1st fight was they're fault its on youtube for anyone to see. Also the shoulder injury that just needed "salt water and prayer" to repair a torn rotator cuff.